Broken Justice, Shattered Innocence / Chapter 2: Ghosts of Maple Heights
Broken Justice, Shattered Innocence

Broken Justice, Shattered Innocence

Author: Amy Cannon


Chapter 2: Ghosts of Maple Heights

I’d hoped I’d get the killer’s script—that would’ve been exciting.

After reading, I glanced up. The others looked a bit pale.

Were they already acting?

I grabbed my beer and took a few gulps: "Hey! You guys done reading? I’m ready to start figuring this out!"

Marcus, next to me, closed his script and stared at Parker across the table, hesitating: "So? Are we moving to the next stage?"

Parker looked around: "This round seems to be for us to give our alibis."

He added, "This script… seems to be a ‘blind killer’ script."

"‘Blind killer’ means the murderer doesn’t even know they’re the murderer."

At this, Lila spoke up: "Then how do you play?"

She snapped her script shut: "If the killer doesn’t even know, do they have to figure it out themselves?"

"Exactly!" Parker said. "That’s the fun of a blind killer script! Basically, you have to figure out if you’re the murderer. If you are, you can lie and mislead us. If you’re not, you have to analyze and find the real culprit!"

During the group discussion, Marcus spoke first.

He cleared his throat: "Last night, I wanted to talk to April about something, but when I went, she wasn’t in her room."

"About what?"

"Something I can’t tell you yet."

Marcus glanced at me, and I nodded in understanding: "I also wanted to talk to April last night, but as soon as I got near Liberty Tower, I saw her jump."

"You saw it yourself?"

I nodded.

Next was Lila, who repeated Marcus’s story. Actually, almost everyone said the same thing:

They wanted to talk to April about something. About what? Uh, something I can’t share yet.

Nothing useful came from this round, so we quickly moved on to the next part of our scripts.

"You have a secret you can’t tell anyone: you like April. You want to confess, but recently you found out she seems to like someone else."

I frowned. It was just a line of text, but I felt a weird sense of déjà vu.

Familiar, but I couldn’t recall why, so I kept reading.

"She always disappears after class. No matter how you look, you can’t find her. You thought she was avoiding you, but a few days later, April suddenly finds you and confesses to you.

You’re happy and want to show her off to your friends, but unexpectedly, April refuses. She firmly tells you:

‘Jake, you absolutely can’t tell anyone!’"

Jake, you can’t tell anyone!

Suddenly, a girl’s voice echoed in my mind, repeating that same line: "Jake, you absolutely can’t tell anyone! Absolutely!"

That sense of familiarity in the script hit me, finally piecing itself into a memory: summer, a girl, a confession.

I remembered!

The words in this script—years ago, a girl had said them to me.

Her name was Lily Barnes.

I liked her. I watched her. And in the end, I saw her leap from the school building.

*April White, Lily Barnes.*

*Liberty Tower, school building.*

*Confession, secret crush.*

Something was wrong with this script!

I jerked my head up, about to tell everyone to stop playing, when suddenly there was a loud THUMP!—Parker collapsed across from me.

He pointed at the script on the table in horror:

"This… this isn’t a murder mystery game—this is a real murder case!"

Flashback:

I met her in high school.

The first time, she was called out by the teacher to stand in the hallway, crying all alone.

At the time, I’d just collected homework and was heading to the office. As soon as I stepped out, I saw her.

Back then, I was a restless teenage boy, always wanting to tease any girl I saw.

So I grinned and walked over: "Hey! Pretty girl in tears!"

Who knew that this little girl—not even as tall as my shoulder—would slap me the next second.

SMACK!

She spat, "Creep!"

I stood there, stunned, homework in hand, not knowing how to react. By the time I snapped out of it, she’d already run off. I was so mad!

From then on, I remembered her.

I swore that next time I saw her, I’d get even!

Later, I asked around and learned her name was Lily Barnes, a nobody from the next class over.

She had good grades, but neither teachers nor classmates liked her. In the bustling school, she was always alone.

Sometimes I thought I should just let it go—a real man can take a slap.

But fate is strange; it made us cross paths again.

The second time was after school.

After my chores, I found my friends had already slipped off to the arcade.

"Jerks!" I mumbled, then dragged the mop to the bathroom to clean it.

By then, the campus was almost empty and quiet.

I could hear water dripping, and occasionally, the faint sound of a girl sobbing.

Wait, a girl crying?

What was a girl doing in the boys’ bathroom?

A chill ran down my spine, and ghost stories flashed through my mind.

"Oh God! Please, don’t haunt me!"

As I prayed, the sobbing stopped. Just as I started to relax, the bathroom door creaked open.

"Crap!"

I jumped at the sudden noise and instinctively looked over.

Then I saw the scariest sight of my life:

A slender, pale hand reached out from the last stall of the boys’ bathroom!

In the silent, dim bathroom, the sound of nails scraping the door made my scalp tingle.

I trembled, and in that moment, thought of all my past misdeeds. I even imagined tomorrow’s headlines:

"Shocking! High school boy dies in the bathroom—tragedy or trouble?"

While I was panicking, a weak voice came from behind the door: "Help... help me..."

You may also like

He Walked Free After Killing Her
He Walked Free After Killing Her
4.6
When a privileged predator murders an innocent college girl, her grieving father begs for justice—but the system rewards silence and connections instead. Trapped between a corrupt mentor and his own conscience, Jimmy must choose: protect his future, or expose the truth behind the courtroom’s dirty deals. In a world where money erases guilt, how much is a life really worth?
Blood Ties: Justice on Trial
Blood Ties: Justice on Trial
4.9
A veteran detective is shaken to his core by a horrific double homicide in a small town, where a young mother and her infant daughter are brutally murdered. As he unravels the case, he battles not only the depravity of the crime but also the insidious influence of wealth and power that threatens to shield the perpetrator from justice. The detective's journey is one of emotional endurance, fierce integrity, and a desperate promise to a grieving husband that justice will prevail—even as the system itself begins to bend.
Broken Promises, Buried Truths
Broken Promises, Buried Truths
4.9
A top student’s quest for justice and survival in a corrupt small town spirals into a deadly chain of cheating, betrayal, and revenge, culminating in a harrowing confession that exposes the dark heart of the system—and the protagonist himself.
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
4.8
When a senator’s twisted heir shatters a farm girl’s body and soul, Maple Heights turns a blind eye—except for one cop. Derek Lane is the only man ruthless enough to drag the town’s monsters into the light, even if it means taking on the Seven Stars Society and the Deacon dynasty. But as secrets bleed and power shields the guilty, can Derek bring justice to a girl whose only crime was honesty?
Framed in Maple Heights
Framed in Maple Heights
4.9
A lie shattered our lives. When my childhood friend Jay was framed for a crime he didn’t commit, the whole town turned its back—except for his sister Marissa, who sacrificed everything to clear his name. But in Maple Heights, loyalty is a double-edged sword: every kindness comes with a price, and the truth is just another secret buried beneath gossip and power. As Marissa’s fight for justice spirals into tragedy and Jay claws his way back with a dangerous new plan, old enemies close in, ready to destroy them all over again. When justice fails and vengeance calls, how far will love go to survive? And when the truth finally comes out, who will be left standing?
Broken Promises, Burning Vengeance
Broken Promises, Burning Vengeance
4.8
A gripping tale of revenge, trauma, and healing set in the world of celebrity, as a woman infiltrates her sister’s tormentor’s life, only to find herself torn between love and justice. The story explores the devastating effects of bullying, the complexity of guilt and forgiveness, and the enduring scars left by betrayal.
Crushed: Hunted for a Child’s Death
Crushed: Hunted for a Child’s Death
4.7
One tragic accident, and my life is shattered—now a furious mother and her vengeful husband want my blood. Trapped in my burning car with a broken leg, the mob’s rage threatens to finish what fate started. The real nightmare? No one cares about the truth—only revenge.
Taken by the Law, Buried by Lies
Taken by the Law, Buried by Lies
4.6
When Daniel Sullivan is detained for lacking ID, his family is plunged into a nightmare—no answers, only a rushed funeral and a death certificate that reeks of cover-up. Bruises on Daniel’s body hint at a brutal secret the city wants to erase. Leonard refuses to let his son become another forgotten victim, vowing to expose the truth even if it destroys him.
Shattered Secrets, Burning Lies
Shattered Secrets, Burning Lies
4.9
When the bones of missing Autumn Harris are discovered in Silver Hollow, a tense class reunion turns into a deadly confrontation. Old friends are forced to confess the truth behind a decade-old tragedy—jealousy, betrayal, and obsession ignite as the group unravels, and the past demands its final price.
Reborn With Vengeance: My Sister, My Weapon
Reborn With Vengeance: My Sister, My Weapon
4.9
Vengeance wears a second skin. Cassie and her sister June died broken, sold and abused in a forgotten Appalachian town. But fate gives them a chilling gift: rebirth in their abusers’ home—and a supernatural Punishment Journal that makes every monster obey. Now, Cassie is the powerless daughter, June the golden son, and together they orchestrate poetic justice for every secret, every scar. But the system’s rules are brutal, and their revenge risks exposing new victims—unless Cassie and June can outwit the town’s deepest evil. As the lines between justice and destruction blur, will their power free the innocent, or damn them all to a second hell? How far would you go to make the past pay?
I Exposed Him—and Saved Her Life
I Exposed Him—and Saved Her Life
4.9
He was Ohio’s most pitied father—until I found the bruises. Fresh out of journalism school, I chased a viral story about a dad livestreaming his daughter’s illness, drawing thousands in donations and a nation’s sympathy. But inside their crumbling apartment, nothing was as it seemed: the girl’s pain ran deeper than disease, and her father’s lies stretched further than anyone guessed. Every question I asked uncovered a new layer of betrayal, desperation, and abuse—until the truth threatened to destroy us all. When the camera stops rolling, who really pays the price? If you could save one life by exposing another’s darkest secret, would you risk everything?
Broken Glory, Stolen Childhood
Broken Glory, Stolen Childhood
5.0
Quinn Delaney survives years of brutal emotional and physical abuse at the hands of her mother, only to discover the life-shattering truth behind her suffering. Through resilience, the support of caring neighbors, and her own determination, she breaks free, confronts her past, and forges a new life and family, reclaiming her future with hope and dignity.