Dumped Online, Chosen by My Best Friend’s Brother

Dumped Online, Chosen by My Best Friend’s Brother

Author: Pooja Khan


Chapter 1: Mic On, Hearts Off

Next →

The sticky heat of a Delhi evening clung to my skin as I queued for another BGMI match. When I was gaming with my online boyfriend, I forgot to mute my mic and called out to my black-and-white cat at home:

"Motu, come here, sit on mummy's lap."

The room buzzed with the low hum of the ceiling fan and the distant clatter of utensils from the neighbour’s kitchen. I didn't realise my voice had travelled straight into my headset—so typical of me, lost in my own world, calling out to my darling without a care.

Usually, he calls me 'baby' every other sentence, but today he was unusually quiet.

I fiddled with my dupatta absently, waiting for his usual teasing—maybe a "arre, meri jaan, focus on the game!" My toe tapped restlessly against the cool tile, matching the fan’s uneven rhythm. But the silence between us was so thick, I could almost hear the neighbour’s TV blaring through the wall. I wondered if he was rolling his eyes, or if my voice had made him smile.

After the game, he suddenly lost his cool.

He cleared his throat, voice lower than usual. For a second, I thought I heard him sigh. "What makes you think I'd want to date a divorced woman with a kid?"

His words stung sharper than the time I bit into a green chilli by mistake. For a moment, I could only stare at my phone screen, heart thumping loudly. It felt as if the entire mohalla had gone quiet just to listen in on my embarrassment. My cheeks burned hotter than the oil in the neighbour’s kadhai.

I complained to my best friend. She sighed in exasperation and said,

"Stop with the online dating and just date my brother instead. Lately, he's been totally smitten with an older divorced woman who has a kid. Every day he's searching for ways to get her child to like him."

Sneha's tone was all mock irritation, but I could hear the concern in her voice—like only a real friend can muster, mixing scolding with real care. The sound of her chewing on roasted peanuts crackled over the call, grounding me in the ordinary chaos of our lives.

---

As a corporate slave slogging through overtime every day, with barely any personal life, my only way to unwind is to play a couple of rounds of BGMI after work. About half a year ago, I got randomly matched with a wild player who'd already reached Ace rank. He played aggressively, hardly spoke, and had a deep, slightly reserved voice—strangely attractive.

My evenings had become a routine: traffic horns fading outside the apartment window, dinner leftovers cooling on the table, and me, curled up with my cracked phone, headset slightly askew. That night, when he first spoke, the usual noise of the city fell away; only his voice mattered.

After weeks of shamelessly calling him "Bhaiya, you're amazing!" and "Bhaiya, carry me!", I finally managed to win him over and started a wild, reckless online romance.

I remember the day he hesitantly asked if he could call me something other than "baby" because it sounded so filmi. I laughed and told him to call me whatever he liked—as long as he kept carrying me to chicken dinner.

"Don't move from the spawn point, I'll come get you," he said in that cool, irresistible voice through my headset, sending a chill down my spine.

His accent—somewhere between Lucknow and Noida—gave even the most mundane instructions a hero's touch. Sometimes, just hearing him say my name made my cheeks burn like a cup of hot chai.

"Bhaiya, that crow guy just shot me—come help me beat him up!" I whined, all while stroking my ginger cat. I was totally in my element, giving orders from my perch on his in-game character's shoulders. I stretched out comfortably, but then, out of the corner of my eye, I saw my sneaky black-and-white cat up on the dining table, reaching for my steel water bottle.

My flat was chaos—cat hair everywhere, stray socks, a pile of unread magazines. The fan squeaked on every rotation, my cats prowled like mini-royalty, and I, the harassed but loving queen, tried to keep everyone in line.

I screeched, "Motu, don't touch mummy's water bottle!" The bottle rolled off the table with a clang, making Motu freeze mid-pounce. Chotu, ever the opportunist, darted in to sniff the spill. I tossed my phone aside and chased after the cat. After a round of chaos, I finally collapsed back on the sofa, only to see the game was already over.

There was a fresh scratch on my wrist and my dupatta nearly dragged through the spilled water, but Motu looked smug as ever. Chotu had taken this opportunity to claim my favourite cushion. Typical.

"Bhaiya, let's keep going. Bas, aaj raat ko thoda try maarte hain, Ace rank pakka!" I put my headset back on, pitched my voice extra sweet, and got ready for the next round. But he didn't ready up for a long time. Just as I was starting to wonder if something was wrong with my headset, he finally spoke.

I could hear my own breathing in the silence, the familiar background buzz of the inverter. His pause was so long, I almost checked if there was a network issue.

"You... what were you just doing?"

Thinking he was confused about my sudden AFK, I hurried to explain, "Oh, it was Motu—he almost broke my water bottle. That's the fourth one this month. If he breaks another, I'll have nothing left to drink from!"

I tried to keep my tone light, but inside I was rolling my eyes. In our house, a dropped bottle is nothing new. My mum would have called it nazar lag gayi to my utensils.

"...You have a child?"

I was baffled. Wait—did he actually think I had a real child? I bit my lip, trying not to laugh. Who doesn't have a fur baby these days? I've seen him show off his golden retriever on his Insta stories all the time. What's the big deal?

Arrey, this boy must be joking. Everyone on my work group has posted at least one photo with their 'kids'—whether it’s a cat, dog, or even a turtle!

"Yeah, all my colleagues have them too. But Motu is just too naughty. I think it's genetic—Chotu is super well-behaved, always cuddling in my arms while I play."

I ran my fingers through Chotu’s fur, feeling his steady purr vibrating against my palm. Sometimes I think these two are the only ones who really listen to me after a long day.

"You have two?"

He sounded like he was barely holding it together, but I couldn't figure out why.

His voice had a tremor I hadn’t heard before, like when you’re about to ask for extra chutney at a street stall and are scared the vendor will say no.

"Yeah, I just didn't want Motu to get lonely at home. With Chotu around, the two kids can play together."

I'm really a great cat mum. I proudly stroked Chotu, who was lying on his back purring in my arms.

In our building, being called a "cat aunty" is a badge of honour, not an insult. I even once got a free bowl of milk from the local dairy uncle for them.

"You've been playing with me for so long, calling me 'bhaiya'... does the kids' dad know?"

His voice was a little shaky. I tilted my head, puzzled. "What does that have to do with their dad? I haven't seen him in ages."

Honestly, men sometimes ask the weirdest questions! Like, what, was I supposed to keep tabs on the entire colony of tomcats?

Motu the black-and-white cat and Chotu the ginger cat were both abandoned at my door in the middle of the night by their irresponsible parents. It's all because I feed stray cats out of sympathy, so I keep getting stuck with these deadbeat dads' kittens. One of these days, I'm going to round up all those tomcats and take them to the vet for a snip.

The colony aunties always say I have too soft a heart. Still, I can’t turn a blind eye when a hungry little face shows up at my door. Maybe it’s a family tradition—my nani was the same.

I grumbled, "If I ever see their dad again, I'll make sure he never has kids again."

He was silent for a long time. I thought I'd scared him.

The only sound was the distant whistle of the pressure cooker from someone’s kitchen, echoing down the corridor.

"Relax, bhaiya. I've already put Motu back in the room—he won't interrupt our game. How about I let Chotu say hi to you? I think he really likes you—every time you talk, he climbs right into my lap..."

But before I could finish, my gaming partner suddenly left the room and went offline.

His abrupt logout felt like the sudden silence after a raucous Diwali cracker burst—unexpected, jarring, leaving a strange emptiness in its wake.

I sent him a question mark on WhatsApp, watching that little "typing..." bubble for ages.

Every second stretched longer than the last. I started flipping through my phone gallery just to distract myself, but my eyes kept darting back.

"Meow~" Chotu rolled over and purred in my arms. I shrugged, confused. Must be bad internet. I'll ask him again tomorrow.

Motu gave me a look as if to say, 'humans are so complicated,' before curling up beside me. I switched on the TV, letting the sound of a saas-bahu serial fill the silence.

I hugged Motu close, pretending the world outside was just another level I could respawn in tomorrow.

Next →

You may also like

Dumped for Dowry, Desired by His Best Friend
Dumped for Dowry, Desired by His Best Friend
4.8
Priya is labelled a gold-digger by her cold, privileged fiancé, who schemes with his best friend to humiliate her into breaking the engagement. But when the best friend falls for Priya’s stubborn spirit, Delhi’s gossip mill spins out of control, and a public showdown exposes every secret. Now, with her reputation in ruins and both men vying for her, Priya must choose between revenge, dignity, and a love she never expected.
Dumped for His Ego, Desired by His Best Friend
Dumped for His Ego, Desired by His Best Friend
4.7
Sneha’s love life is a battlefield: public humiliation, endless cold wars, and Rohan’s ex always waiting in the wings. When Rohan finally pushes her too far, Sneha posts a bold 'Happy breakup'—and suddenly, his friends, including her sworn enemy Kabir, are lining up for a chance at her heart. But as old wounds bleed into new flirtations, will Sneha choose freedom, or fall for the one man who always claimed to hate her?
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Shame
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Shame
4.7
I only wanted a safe ride home, but my brother sent Kabir—the campus heartthrob who once caught me at my most embarrassing moment. One midnight pickup, a million misunderstandings, and now I’ve seen him in nothing but his bedsheet! With my family watching and my heart racing, how can I ever face Kabir—or my brother—again?
My Brother’s Best Friend Calls Me ‘Cat’
My Brother’s Best Friend Calls Me ‘Cat’
4.6
Everyone thinks I’m the obedient, sweet ‘good girl’—except Kabir, my brother’s fierce best friend and India’s hottest ex-esports star. Alone together in my brother’s flat, he scolds me, cooks for me, and secretly calls me ‘cat’ on his livestream, never knowing I’m his number one fan. But when he starts warning off my college seniors and teasing me with a possessive glare, I wonder—am I just Bhaiya’s little sister, or the girl he can’t resist?
Rejected the Rich Boy, Chose the Labourer
Rejected the Rich Boy, Chose the Labourer
4.9
Everyone expected me to say yes to the college’s golden boy, but I shocked them all by running into the arms of Rohan—the poor labourer with cement-stained hands and a heart that still aches from my betrayal. Now, with the real heroine Priya in the picture and my ex plotting revenge, I must fight for a love I once threw away. But in this city of secrets, can a girl like me ever rewrite her fate, or am I doomed to always be the second lead?
Dumped for the Streamer, Reborn as His Boss
Dumped for the Streamer, Reborn as His Boss
4.7
When Ritu’s boyfriend Arjun, now a league champion, publicly ditches her for a viral gamer girl, the whole country mocks her as the ‘doosri ladki’. Betrayed and humiliated, Ritu refuses to fade away—instead, she recruits a rookie prodigy and vows to crush Arjun’s new ‘power couple’ on the battlefield he abandoned her for. In a world where loyalty is currency and the crowd never forgives, will Ritu rise from the ashes or be written out for good?
Dumped for Not Paying the Bride Price
Dumped for Not Paying the Bride Price
4.7
Rohan thought his heartfelt birthday surprise would melt Ananya’s heart, but her friends turned his love into a public humiliation—demanding five lakhs on UPI or declaring him a kanjoos makhi choos. As wine splashes and insults fly, Rohan’s dream gift remains a secret, while Ananya stands with her squad against him. When family pride and toxic friendships clash, will love survive—or will Rohan walk away, realizing he was always just an outsider?
She Chose My Rival Over Me
She Chose My Rival Over Me
4.8
He loved Ananya with his whole heart, but the world decided he was never good enough. Humiliated by teachers, abandoned by friends, and forced to watch his perfect rival claim her side, he became the invisible boy whose only crime was loving too much. When even his mother must beg for his place, will he fight for love—or accept that some stories are meant to end in regret?
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
He Chose Her, I Chose Myself
4.6
After two years chasing Mumbai’s college heartthrob, Meera is humiliated when he publicly claims another girl—and leaves her to face cruel whispers and betrayal alone. But when he finally comes begging, Meera refuses to cry or cling, stunning everyone by choosing her dreams over his drama. On the day she leaves for a new life abroad, he realizes too late: the girl he took for granted is gone for good.
Rejected by My Childhood Fiancé
Rejected by My Childhood Fiancé
4.7
Everyone expected Ananya to choose Kabir—the golden boy she’d loved since childhood. But when she finally confesses, she discovers his heart belongs to someone else, and her own family’s pride becomes her prison. Torn between a loyal army officer and the boy who never wanted her, Ananya must break free from generations of expectations, even if it means returning every memory Kabir ever gave her.
Betrayed at My Best Friend’s Wedding
Betrayed at My Best Friend’s Wedding
4.9
Ananya spent eight years loving Rohan, dreaming of forever—until, at her best friend’s shaadi, he abandoned her for another girl in front of the entire family. Humiliated in the crowd, forced to drink and called a liar, she stumbles upon Rohan’s ultimate betrayal behind closed doors. In the chaos of fairy lights and marigold garlands, Ananya must decide: will she beg for his love, or walk away from the ruins of her own heart?
My Online Boyfriend Was India’s Gaming God
My Online Boyfriend Was India’s Gaming God
4.8
Kuhu thought her online romance was all fun and games—until her 'fake' pro player boyfriend crushed her in a public match, exposing both their secrets before the whole Indian server. Betrayed, blocked, and heartbroken, she tries to move on—until a viral esports showdown reveals his true superstar identity, and her own family’s tangled ties to his world. Can she reclaim her pride and love, or will their double life end in game over?