My Boyfriend’s Brother Took My First Night

My Boyfriend’s Brother Took My First Night

Author: Brett Donaldson


Chapter 1: The Wrong Room

Next →

The house was dark and unfamiliar. The air smelled like fresh laundry and old wood, with the low, steady hum of the fridge somewhere in the background. Sometime after midnight, the covers shifted beside me. Someone slid into bed, their movements careful but sure. My pajama top bunched up at my ribs, letting in a sudden chill across my skin.

My mind, heavy with sleep, tried to make sense of it. "Derek, quit messing around," I mumbled, my voice thick, still half-lost in dreams. I reached out, expecting my boyfriend’s playful touch.

But there was no answer. Instead, warm lips brushed the curve of my neck, soft but insistent, sending goosebumps racing up my arms. His hands roamed with a confidence Derek never had—nothing shy or hesitant about it.

A sharp, sweet whiff of whiskey hit me. Derek never drank, especially not at home. My heart skipped. Was this Derek? Or had I wandered into the wrong room? But the lips kept moving, and I wanted so badly to believe it was him.

I froze, torn between the comfort of a familiar embrace and a gnawing sense that something was off. Still, I let my arms circle his neck, chasing warmth even as doubt prickled down my spine. My thoughts blurred, lost in the moment and the steady hum of the AC kicking on.

"Hey, bro, you in there?"

Derek’s voice rang clear from the hallway, unmistakable. Every muscle in my body locked up, my heart hammering.

If Derek was outside—then who was inside the room with me?

Next →

You may also like

Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
4.7
I thought coming home would mean awkward family dinners, not waking up my brother’s dangerously hot best friend—bare, flustered, and inches away from disaster. Now, every secret crush and forbidden memory is crashing back, but Miles Carter is strictly off-limits. If my brother finds out what happened that morning, it won’t just be my heart on the line—it’ll be our whole family’s peace.
Forbidden With My Stepbrother
Forbidden With My Stepbrother
4.9
Rachel’s world unravels when she discovers her quiet, obedient stepbrother harbors a love for her that’s anything but brotherly. As past guilt and simmering attraction collide, she’s forced to choose between the dangerous thrill of taboo desire and the safety of playing by the rules. But with the eyes of fate—and a relentless stream of live comments—watching her every move, will she surrender to a love she’s always denied?
Sold to My Stepbrother for Survival
Sold to My Stepbrother for Survival
4.7
My mother betrayed our country and traded my innocence for her own ambition, casting me as a pawn in her ruthless game. Forced into my stepbrother’s bed to escape my predatory stepfather, I became the ghost princess of a house built on blood and lies. Now, guilt and forbidden love threaten to destroy what little I have left—unless I betray him, too.
Her Bros or Her Boyfriend: Choose Me or Him
Her Bros or Her Boyfriend: Choose Me or Him
4.6
Natalie swears her late nights with the guys are harmless, but every hug, every secret gift, drives Caleb to the edge. When he brings home a gorgeous new female 'bro,' Natalie finally tastes her own medicine—and can't handle the sting. As jealousy and betrayal ignite, Caleb must decide: fight for the girl who keeps breaking his heart, or walk away for good?
My Brother Stole My Second Chance
My Brother Stole My Second Chance
4.9
Forced to choose between his future and his brother’s, Danny draws the long straw—then spends his life paying the price for his family’s favoritism. When fate gives him a second shot, he refuses to sacrifice himself again, risking everything to break free. But with every door slammed in his face, Danny must fight for his own survival—or lose himself all over again.
Fake Dating My Best Friend’s Brother
Fake Dating My Best Friend’s Brother
4.6
One drunken night with my best friend’s perfect, untouchable brother ruined every boundary I swore I’d keep. Now Nathan wants me to fake date him to dodge his family’s matchmaking—while I’m hiding the truth from his sister, my only real friend. If Tanya finds out what really happened between us, I’ll lose everything… and Nathan might just break my heart for good.
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
4.7
Sam gave up his dreams and moved to Rachel’s hometown, only to become the outsider in his own marriage—her childhood ‘brother’ Jake always comes first. Every boundary Sam sets is laughed off, but when he brings his own female friend to dinner, Rachel’s jealousy explodes. As their marriage unravels, Sam realizes he’s just a guest in Rachel’s perfect family sitcom—and he’s finally done playing the fool.
Claimed by My Brother’s Roommate
Claimed by My Brother’s Roommate
4.7
On the heels of her 28th birthday, Natalie is kicked out by her mom and rescued by Derek—her brother’s quiet, hyper-competent roommate. What starts as shared dinners and one shocking mall misunderstanding spirals into a forbidden slow-burn where Natalie must choose between secrecy and the love she’s yearned for. If she gambles her heart, she could lose her family—or finally claim the man who’s been hers all along.
I’m His Fiancée, But He’s Her Secret
I’m His Fiancée, But He’s Her Secret
4.9
He was my first heartbreak—and now, as the fiancée of a wealthy man with too many secrets, I’m about to meet the ghosts I thought I’d buried. I was always the 'good girl,' the safe choice, until a proposal ring and a scandalous pregnancy upended my carefully planned life. Carter offers security, but his world is full of women I’ll never measure up to—and tonight, he’s inviting me into his circle for the first time. But nothing prepares me for who’s waiting there: Tyler, the wild love I never got over. When midnight falls and old wounds resurface, will I cling to the future I chose, or risk everything for the boy who broke me? When your heart is split between comfort and chaos, which do you betray?
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
4.8
When I defend a classmate from public humiliation, she turns her gratitude toward my boyfriend—and then invades every corner of our lives. Betrayed and blindsided, I fight to keep my love and dignity as a cunning rival spins a web of lies and sabotage. With my relationship and reputation at stake, I must decide: stand my ground or lose everything to the girl I tried to save.
I Bought a Boy, He Bought My Heart
I Bought a Boy, He Bought My Heart
4.9
He was the beautiful boy I bought out of a fight club, a broken thing desperate to be mine. But behind Dylan’s obedient smile hid a wolf’s hunger—and a secret that could shatter my world. As I climbed the ranks of Silver Hollow’s business elite, Dylan was always there: loyal, dangerous, and dangerously in love. But when my family forced me into an engagement with another man, Dylan’s possessive side exploded, crashing the party and revealing he was heir to the city’s most feared dynasty. Now everyone wants a piece of us—rivals, exes, and even family—but all I want is the boy who would burn down the world for me. Can I survive the storm I unleashed, or will loving my dangerous ‘pet’ cost me everything? When pride and obsession collide, who will be left standing—the business queen, or her secret billionaire wolf?
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.