My Niece Played Me Twice / Chapter 1: The Call That Changed Everything
My Niece Played Me Twice

My Niece Played Me Twice

Author: Jack Marsh


Chapter 1: The Call That Changed Everything

Next →

My younger half-brother got into a car accident. I didn’t even have time to process the news before my phone rang—Nathaniel, barely holding it together, begging me to take in his daughter from his hospital bed. The desperation in his voice said it all, but the whole thing still felt unreal, like I’d been shoved into the middle of a nightmare I hadn’t seen coming.

The air in my apartment grew thick as I pressed the phone to my ear. I could hear the city humming outside—cars rolling by, horns in the distance—but it all felt far away. Nathaniel’s voice trembled, and I could practically picture him clinging to the hospital bed rail, knuckles gone pale. I swallowed, feeling that old ache in my chest. Family. It always finds a way to pull you back.

Just as I was about to say yes, a flood of voices crashed through my mind like a hallucination—sarcastic, sharp, and relentless:

"Your brother’s faking it. Don’t fall for it. He just wants you to raise that ungrateful brat, then take the fall when you’re left with nothing!"

"That little vixen is ruthless—sharp as a tack, cold as ice!"

"You’ve always been the family workhorse, sacrificing everything for everyone else!"

"Even after you die, they’ll accuse you of child abuse, drag you through court, and you’ll be stuck in a nightmare for a decade..."

The words zipped past like a news crawl at the bottom of the screen, piling up faster than I could even blink. Each one hit like a slap. My scalp tingled and a cold sweat crept down my back—the kind you get when you realize the rollercoaster’s about to drop. No way off. Not this time.

Nathaniel, still on the line, sounded desperate: “Dude, come on, say something! You’re the only family I can trust!”

I could hear him breathing hard on the other end. For a second, I almost gave in—almost. But those comments kept buzzing in my ears, drowning him out, louder than anything he said.

I changed my tone. “We’re only half-brothers. Shouldn’t your stepmom handle this? Isn’t she your real family now? Why am I the one you’re calling?”

I surprised myself with how cold I sounded. The words just spilled out, like some invisible hand was shoving a script in front of me, telling me to keep my guard up. Nathaniel went quiet. I could picture him frowning. “Dude, what are you talking about?”

I hit airplane mode and killed the call.

"Sorry, can’t hear you. Gotta hang up."

The comments blew up, like a crowd at a football game.

"He finally figured it out. Can he actually see us now?"

"Last time he was so clueless, I almost threw my phone. Parents gone, and this brother just wants to take everything—how can’t he see it?"

"The worst was when the little vixen betrayed him, that look on his face when the cops pinned him down!"

......

I stared at the phone, the comments still buzzing like static I couldn’t turn off. Turns out, I’m stuck in some kind of reality show—some cosmic rerun—and this is my second time through.

According to the script, I lost my parents young, and my gambling brother cleaned me out. They faked a death and dumped his scheming daughter on me.

The whole thing felt like a twisted soap opera. Only, the pain? That was real. Years later, I lost my home and savings, and then that little wolf accused me of being a predator—ended up wasting away in jail.

I couldn’t help it—my fists clenched. The comments just wouldn’t stop.

The air seemed to vibrate around me, the radiator ticked in the silence. I barely noticed. Suddenly, a new warning flashed across my mind:

"Still just standing there? Stepmom’s about to be at your door!"

"Run! That old bat’s trouble—she’ll force you to sign guardianship!"

"Tsk tsk, the little vixen’s about to show up. Last time she cried so pretty it broke my heart, but her heart’s stone cold!"

Someone pounded on my door. Hard.

My stepmother—broad-shouldered and booming—shouted from the hallway: “Colin Pierce, get out here! Your brother died so tragically, you heartless jerk, why’d you refuse his last wish?”

Her voice rattled the door, echoing down the hallway. I could just imagine the neighbors turning down their TVs, peeking out their peepholes. “Just because your dad’s gone doesn’t mean you, some orphan, can do whatever you want. I’m your mom—even if I’m your stepmom. Show some respect!”

No way was I opening the door. This old bat was legendary for her temper and her razor-sharp tongue. I let out a sigh, remembering the time she threw a frying pan at Nathaniel for coming home late.

I could picture her. Arms crossed. Eyes narrowed. Ready to unleash hell.

Suddenly, she changed tactics.

“Colin, if you don’t open up, I’ll make a scene right here. Let’s see how you keep your job after that!”

My job at the county clerk’s office? One whiff of scandal and I’d be out.

Small towns never forget. I could practically hear the whispers already—county offices thrive on gossip, and news spreads faster than a brush fire. She was ready to ruin me if it meant getting her way.

Just as my hand brushed the doorknob, a warning zapped through my mind:

"Don’t open it, it’s a trap!"

"You always open it. That old witch will have you under her thumb."

Next →

You may also like

My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
4.9
Sometimes, the person you love most comes back as someone else. When my sister wakes up convinced she's a debutante from another century, my family is thrown into chaos—and I'm the only one who sees the truth behind her haunted eyes. As Lila stumbles through smartphones and SAT prep, I teach her about freedom, love, and the world that should have been hers. But when a car crash swaps our souls across time, I wake up in a past where women are prisoners and my real sister is a ghost. To survive, we must outwit cruel fathers, possessive cousins, and the rules of two different worlds—until a desperate ritual offers one last shot at home. What will we lose to return—and what if the girl we saved is the one we can never let go? When fate gives you a second chance, can you rewrite your own story?
His Twin Played Me for a Year
His Twin Played Me for a Year
4.8
For three years, Harper was Ethan Grant’s secret, never knowing the cruel game played behind her back. Pregnant and betrayed, she discovers the man she loves isn’t who she thought—his twin brother has been taking his place in the dark. Now, as their twisted wedding countdown begins, Harper must decide: run before their trap closes, or turn the tables on the elite who ruined her life.
Mistaken Kiss: Trapped Between Twin Sisters
Mistaken Kiss: Trapped Between Twin Sisters
4.7
One drunken mistake—kissing the wrong twin—spirals Derek into a nightmare of betrayal, blackmail, and forbidden obsession. Now, Nicole wants nothing to do with him, while Natalie demands he pretend to be her boyfriend or risk losing everything. Caught between sisters who look identical but want wildly different things, Derek must decide: confess, escape, or surrender to the twisted game he never meant to play.
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
4.7
Everyone adored my perfect sister—except me, who knew the secrets behind her shining trophies and forced smiles. Raised to sacrifice everything for me, Summer’s only moment of freedom ended in blood and blame, and from that day, her happiness vanished for good. Now she swears she’ll ruin my life, but the truth is, I already ruined hers—and no one in our picture-perfect Ohio town has a clue.
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
4.7
I watched helplessly as my little sister was lured into a nightmare by the girl she trusted most, only to be betrayed and trapped in a cruel small-town ritual. When I tried to save her, they killed me—now I’ve woken in the past, desperate to rewrite fate and stop the wedding night horror before it begins. But the whole town is in on the secret, and one wrong move means losing her forever.
Reborn as My Sister’s Shadow
Reborn as My Sister’s Shadow
4.7
On the day our marriage finally shattered, Derek and I died in a crash—only to wake up as teenagers, forced to relive the nightmare of loving the same perfect girl: my twin, Natalie. This time, I refuse to be her stand-in, refuse to let my mother’s cruelty and Derek’s obsession crush me again. But fate is twisted—Derek remembers everything too, and Natalie’s secrets run deeper than anyone knows. If I don’t break free, I’ll be trapped in her shadow forever.
Heir’s Pawn, Twice Betrayed
Heir’s Pawn, Twice Betrayed
4.9
He was the heir I saved from the fire—the man who would become both my salvation and my undoing. When Gabriel Whitmore returned to claim his fortune, the town buzzed with secrets, but no one knew I’d lived this moment before. In another life, I asked for love and became a pawn in their games—betrayed, locked away, poisoned by the girl who wore white at his side. This time, I bow my head and ask only for safety, but the Whitmore estate is a maze of old grudges and new dangers. Judge Langley plots, Gabriel’s heart hardens, and I must decide if survival means giving up on hope forever. Can I break free of the cycle, or will history repeat itself—one heartbreak at a time?
Swapped at Birth: The System’s Real Daughter
Swapped at Birth: The System’s Real Daughter
4.7
Natalie has always been second best—bullied at school, ignored by her own mother, and forced to serve the perfect heiress Lillian. But when a mysterious app offers her a one-time life swap, Natalie’s revenge will expose the truth: she’s the real daughter of the wealthy Hayes family, stolen at birth. With the whole school watching, she risks everything for a shot at love, justice, and the top spot—even if it means burning every bridge behind her.
The Night Grandma Swung the Dead Girl
The Night Grandma Swung the Dead Girl
4.8
When a call reports a little girl and her grandmother swinging in the dark, officers arrive to a nightmare: the child is dead, but the old woman keeps pushing her, lost in a memory loop. As grief, guilt, and dementia blur reality, a video reveals the girl’s final moments—her face twisted in terror, her corpse letting out an impossible, haunting laugh. Was it just a tragic accident, or did something unspeakable happen on the playground that night?
Stand-In Stole My Life
Stand-In Stole My Life
4.7
Sent to wed an enemy leader at fifteen, Natalie returns five years later to find a stand-in living her life—her parents stolen, her future hijacked, and her first love in someone else’s arms. Poisoned, betrayed, and reborn in a time loop, she seizes power in a cutthroat capital, determined to expose the impostor who tried to erase her. If she plays her cards right, she’ll rewrite the past—and make everyone who used her choke on their own lies.
Married Off for My Best Friend’s Game
Married Off for My Best Friend’s Game
4.7
Lillian was forced to marry Caleb—her best friend’s pawn and the golden boy of their small town. Used as a shield in Natalie’s twisted love triangle, she endures betrayal, public shame, and a marriage built on lies. But when secrets come to light and Caleb finally sees her, Lillian must decide if she’ll keep playing the supporting role…or rewrite the rules for good.