Roommates After Dark / Chapter 2: Crossing the Line
Roommates After Dark

Roommates After Dark

Author: Kimberly Hamilton


Chapter 2: Crossing the Line

My bedroom was the master, just steps from the bathroom. Natalie’s room was farther inside, down a stretch of dim hallway where the lightbulb had burned out ages ago. Every time we crossed paths there, it felt like a scene from a coming-of-age movie—shadows, secrets, and the sense that anything could happen.

I froze. Never in a million years did I expect to find a slim, twenty-year-old girl in a pink towel walking toward me in that shadowy hallway.

She blinked, hesitating, shifting her weight from one foot to the other. For a moment, we were both caught—equal parts embarrassed and amused.

We stood there for what felt like forever, the only sound the fridge humming from the kitchen. The tension was thick enough to cut with a butter knife.

We both glanced at the bathroom door, then at each other, silently admitting we’d both been caught in the act—half-dressed, neither wanting to explain.

Suddenly, the front door clunked open. The roommate’s hurried footsteps and muffled chatter echoed down the hallway. No way could we just stand there like this.

My cheeks flushed, panic prickling my skin. I darted back into my room, leaving the door open a crack.

"Don’t close it, let me in too," Natalie said, her hand on the frame as she squeezed in behind me. Her towel brushed my arm as she ducked inside, breathing a relieved sigh.

As soon as the bedroom door shut, we heard the roommate’s keys and shopping bags clattering in the living room, her voice drifting toward the kitchen.

She was already banging pans together and humming along to some pop song. It was like she always knew when people needed privacy.

"Why’d she come back so early today?" I tried to sound casual, but my heart hammered in my chest. I glanced at Natalie, who still clutched her towel with both hands.

"Maybe she’s getting ready to cook," Natalie replied, rolling her eyes with a hint of mischief. "Washing pots, chopping veggies again."

We lingered by the door, listening to the sizzle from the kitchen. Every second felt longer than the last.

"She seems to be staying in the living room now," Natalie whispered. Her voice was gentle, sweet, and a little breathless. "So awkward. Looks like we’re trapped in here. If we go out, she’ll see us for sure."

I pictured the look we’d get from the roommate—a sly grin, a story spreading by the next day. No way did either of us want to become the apartment gossip.

Natalie held the door, knuckles white, eyes darting from the couch to the window. She kept glancing at the handle, like she could will the situation to end by sheer force of will.

Seeing I was silent, she added, "Looks like I’ll have to hide in your room for a while." Her voice was shaky, but she tried to sound casual.

So the two of us just stood there, not moving, not sitting, letting the silence stretch heavy as wet laundry.

Originally, I’d planned to just watch some YouTube videos and relax before my shower. Now, with Natalie standing inches away—wrapped in nothing but a towel and smelling faintly of shampoo—I found it impossible to focus on anything else.

My mind raced, body tense. I tried to keep my eyes on the floor, but curiosity kept winning.

I looked at Natalie, took a deep breath, and slowly let it out, trying to steady my nerves.

"Sit for a while," I said, gesturing to the old gray couch pushed up against the wall, trying to play it cool, even as my heart pounded.

You may also like

My Roommates Are Ghosts, Not Friends
My Roommates Are Ghosts, Not Friends
4.8
I thought my college dorm drama was just roommate fights—until I saw a man climb into their beds at midnight and vanish by dawn. When the truth hit, my 'friends' weren’t human, and the old carpenter who sold me a threshold had a chilling secret: my room sits on a mass grave, and I’m the next target for a supernatural scheme. Now I’m caught between a ghost-refining master, a blood ritual, and the only person I trust is 300 miles away—if I don’t play this right, I’ll be the next girl to disappear.
Roommates With No Boundaries
Roommates With No Boundaries
4.5
When broke blogger Jake lands a dirt-cheap New York apartment, he doesn’t expect to share it with Rachel—a gorgeous, chaotic stranger whose secrets run deeper than her messes. Living together means every awkward line gets crossed: missing underwear, ruined work, and accidental naked encounters. But as their walls crumble, Jake discovers the truth behind Rachel’s laughter—and just how much heartbreak she’s hiding.
Roommates & Red Flags
Roommates & Red Flags
4.7
Ethan's fresh start in Chicago turns chaotic when he becomes the only guy sharing an apartment with seven unpredictable women. As he navigates awkward encounters, career anxiety, and the wild realities of city life, every day brings new embarrassments—and the possibility of unexpected belonging. Will he survive the madness or crack under the pressure?
Roommate Rival, Midnight Lover
Roommate Rival, Midnight Lover
4.9
Derek has spent his entire college life hiding the truth about his intersex body and his forbidden crush on his perfect, aloof roommate, Marcus. But when a single accident shatters his carefully constructed lies, Derek faces the ultimate risk: will Marcus reject him, or could their rivalry turn into something dangerously intimate? Everything Derek has ever feared—and hoped for—hangs in the balance.
Neighbors, Rules, and Shared Beds
Neighbors, Rules, and Shared Beds
4.9
Dylan, a young Chicago transplant, finds his carefully guarded solitude disrupted by Rachel, his charming Southern roommate. Amidst the chaos of an overcrowded apartment and a city that never sleeps, the two are thrust into an unconventional living arrangement that blurs the line between friendship and something more. As their boundaries break and routines intertwine, Dylan must confront his feelings, his fears, and what it truly means to let someone in.
The Red Heels in My Dorm Room
The Red Heels in My Dorm Room
4.7
Every night at 2AM, laughter and sobbing echo through Ethan’s dorm, but no one admits to hearing it—except the dead. When his roommate’s girlfriend leaves in a pair of ghostly red heels, bodies start piling up and reality unravels. Now, Ethan must face the horrifying truth: some secrets never leave the room, and some guests never check out.
My Roommate Isn’t Human
My Roommate Isn’t Human
4.9
Alex thought rent and roommate drama were the worst parts of shared living—until a midnight text traps him in a deadly game with rules that don’t make sense. As paranoia rips the group apart and one by one they vanish, Alex must figure out who—or what—doesn’t belong, before he’s next. Trust the wrong person, and you’re gone for good.
Roommate Roulette: Kiss, Cry, Repeat
Roommate Roulette: Kiss, Cry, Repeat
4.9
Carter Brooks never expected to fall for his roommate, Eli—especially after a viral mishap, a supernatural option box, and a string of disastrous misunderstandings. As Carter stumbles through jealousy, public confessions, and family chaos, he must confront his feelings before he loses Eli for good. Will he choose love or let fear keep them apart?
Blind in the Killer’s Lair
Blind in the Killer’s Lair
4.8
I came home to the scent of my roommate’s cologne—hours before cops swarmed our apartment and told me he’d been murdered while I slept. The killer left a bloody message: 'Lucky you’re a blind man, right.' Now, trapped in the darkness, I realize the murderer may still be here... and I’m the only witness who never saw his face.
My Roommate’s Boyfriend Was Never Alive
My Roommate’s Boyfriend Was Never Alive
5.0
When Natalie dreams of a mysterious phone number and DMs the handsome stranger behind it, her college life explodes with gossip, jealousy, and a spiraling obsession. But as her roommate Tanya warns of a chilling truth, Natalie’s crush becomes a nightmare that could cost them all their souls. One wrong message, and they’ve unleashed something they can’t escape.
My Roommate Tried to Slice Me Open
My Roommate Tried to Slice Me Open
4.9
Morgan thought college would be ordinary—until her sleepwalking roommate Natalie nearly attacked her with a knife, haunted by dreams of watermelons and secrets. When a real murder rocks their dorm, suspicion, terror, and betrayal threaten to tear their friendship apart. But as the truth is revealed, Morgan must decide if forgiveness is possible—or if nightmares can really come true.
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
4.8
I thought I was gaming my way home—until I realized I’d seduced the wrong man: Chase Milton, the infamous horror boss who hates men like me. Now I’m trapped as his college roommate, desperate to hide my secret and survive a year without losing my head… or my heart. But when the truth comes out, will he destroy me, or is the real danger falling for the monster I unleashed?