Seduced by the Church’s Dark Secret / Chapter 6: Poison and Paranoia
Seduced by the Church’s Dark Secret

Seduced by the Church’s Dark Secret

Author: Patrick Morrison


Chapter 6: Poison and Paranoia

While I was speaking with Rachel, the man from before turned and left the basement.

His footsteps faded up the stairs, leaving behind a nervous hush. Rachel clung to me a moment longer before finally stepping back, brushing at her tears.

Moments later, he returned, bringing with him an old man dressed in black.

The new arrival wore a suit that had seen better days, the collar frayed, the lapels shiny with age. He carried himself like he owned the place, eyes sharp and cold.

The old man introduced himself as the man’s pastor.

He spoke with practiced ease, offering a handshake I accepted out of habit. There was something off about him—a quiet arrogance, the kind you only see in small-town authority figures used to being obeyed.

Judging by the disciple’s respectful attitude, the old man clearly held some status.

The assistant stood a step behind, head bowed, hands folded. It was the kind of deferential body language I’d seen in church basements all across America—respect bordering on fear.

"I heard from my assistant that a miracle occurred here, so I came to see for myself." The old man had Rachel step aside and stood before me.

He spoke in a soft, commanding tone, like a doctor about to deliver bad news. His eyes scanned me with clinical detachment.

"Mind if I take a look at your hand, son?" he asked, reaching out.

He extended his palm, waiting for me to comply. I hesitated a fraction too long before giving in—better to play along and keep him guessing.

I offered my hand, and the moment our skin touched, I felt a surge of energy probe my body.

A shiver ran down my spine. It was like being frisked at the airport, only far more invasive—a subtle, searching pressure.

Judging by the quality, he was at best a minor practitioner, nowhere near my level.

His energy was thin, scattered—a cheap imitation of real power. I felt a twinge of pity, mixed with annoyance.

Only seven or eight major steps below me.

He wasn’t even in the same league. In my old life, I’d have brushed him aside without a second thought.

In the past, I would have cut him down with a single stroke.

I remembered the old days—the thrill of a quick duel, the satisfaction of victory. But those days were over. Now, caution was my best weapon.

But now, I know how to bide my time.

Patience didn’t come easy, but I’d learned my lesson. Sometimes, survival means knowing when to keep your blade sheathed.

After all, in my previous life, it was my recklessness that led to Rachel’s death.

The memory was fresh, sharp as ever. I wouldn’t make the same mistake twice.

Later, I overestimated myself and tried to challenge true great beings, nearly annihilating my own soul.

That kind of arrogance nearly cost me everything. Now, I kept my ambitions small, my movements careful.

Now, not knowing this man’s true background, I dare not act rashly.

I watched him closely, looking for tells—a twitch of the eye, a tremor in his voice. Anything that might betray his true intentions.

Besides, all I want is a peaceful life with Rachel. As for disputes, I’d rather avoid them if I can.

I’d had enough of violence and intrigue. These days, my dreams were simple: a hot meal, a warm bed, a family to come home to.

The old man’s energy roamed through my body, finally revealing his true purpose: he wanted to activate the poison within me.

I felt the subtle nudge, the way you sense someone watching you from across the street. But my defenses held firm—he found nothing.

But I had already digested the poison, so he naturally found nothing.

His brow furrowed, lips pressed into a thin line. He tried again, more forceful this time, but it was useless.

"This medicine on the table," the old man frowned, "did you really drink it?"

His suspicion was palpable. He glanced at the bowl, then back at me, eyes narrowing.

I nodded.

I kept my expression blank, shoulders relaxed. I’d learned long ago not to give away too much.

"Then why didn’t you finish it? I checked just now—your body is still very weak, you could die at any time."

He spoke with the confidence of someone used to being right. I resisted the urge to roll my eyes.

I couldn’t be bothered to argue, so I simply tipped back the bowl and finished the rest of the poison in one gulp.

The liquid was thick and bitter, burning a trail down my throat. I forced myself to swallow, keeping my face neutral.

The old man was delighted and prepared to repeat his trick, but I shook off his hand and feigned distress, clutching my head. "Oh man, my head hurts so much!"

I played it up, groaning loudly. Theatrics had always been my strong suit—sometimes, you just have to lean into the role.

Then I got up and took Rachel’s hand. "Rachel, my head is killing me. Quick, take me outside for some fresh air."

I squeezed her hand, putting just enough weight behind the words to make it seem urgent. She nodded, her worry written all over her face.

With that, she supported me as we walked out of the basement.

The stairs creaked beneath our feet, the air growing fresher with every step. The sunlight waiting above felt like a blessing.

As expected, the old man and his assistant didn’t stop us.

They watched us go, frustration simmering just below the surface. I could feel their eyes on my back the whole way up.

In that brief exchange, I had already sensed the old man’s murderous intent.

It was there in the tension of his jaw, the way his hand lingered just a little too long. I’d seen that look before—in the eyes of men about to do something they couldn’t take back.

I don’t know why, but he seemed determined to see me dead.

Maybe it was fear, or maybe it was something deeper—a need to assert control over something he didn’t understand.

If I finished the medicine and didn’t die, he’d likely make his move for real.

It was a dangerous game, and I was walking a razor’s edge. I hoped my performance was convincing enough.

At that point, while I could kill him in an instant, if there were any true great beings nearby, I might not be able to hide my strength.

The risk was too great. One wrong move, and I could bring the whole weight of the church down on us.

After all, judging by their tone, they seemed to worship this Madonna.

I’d seen enough small-town cults to know how dangerous blind faith could be. The Madonna was more than just a name—she was the power behind the throne.

And from experience, anyone who is worshipped is likely a great being who protects a region.

You don’t mess with the local legends. Every town has one—the kind of story parents use to scare their kids straight. The Madonna was no different.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

The Pastor Claimed My Fox Spirit Body
The Pastor Claimed My Fox Spirit Body
4.8
I broke into Silver Hollow Church for a taste of forbidden magic, but ended up trapped by a venom-crazed pastor who shattered every vow—leaving my fox spirit branded with his holy mark. Now, hunted by his task force and stripped of my most sacred secret, I’m torn between vengeance and the feverish pull of the man who ruined me. If he exposes what happened that night, I’ll lose my power, my freedom, and my heart.
My Tutor’s Seductive Secret
My Tutor’s Seductive Secret
4.8
When a college kid gets stranded overnight at his student’s mom’s house, desire and danger collide. What starts as playful flirtation turns into a twisted game when he stumbles on a chilling clue—and realizes he might not make it out alive. Will passion save him, or is he just another victim of her dark past?
Rescued by the Broken Heroine
Rescued by the Broken Heroine
5.0
Disguised as a man to survive, the narrator risks everything to rescue a legendary war heroine shattered by betrayal and violence. Hunted across the Southwest, she hides in a church where a second fallen woman waits, her own secrets locked behind suspicion and scars. If trust fails tonight, both women—and the narrator’s last hope—will be lost forever.
Sainted Too Soon
Sainted Too Soon
4.9
Father Thomas returns home a hero after enduring a lifetime of trials, only to find his hard-won glory threatened by a young, impossibly perfect rival. As whispers of favoritism and corruption swirl, Thomas must confront the painful truth: in a world obsessed with shortcuts, is there still room for real sacrifice? His faith, legacy, and self-worth hang in the balance.
Trapped in the Golden Bowl: The Odyssey Game
Trapped in the Golden Bowl: The Odyssey Game
4.7
Waking up in a blood-soaked church basement, I’m forced to play priest to three monstrous strangers—each hiding a deadly hunger and a secret agenda. The rules of survival are twisted: obey the wrong command and you’re meat, but refuse and you break the code, risking a fate worse than death. Now, trapped inside a cursed golden bowl, I must outwit the cannibals and the false Redeemer, all while hiding the truth—I’m not the real Father, and one wrong move will expose me to slaughter.
Bought Her Innocence From Her Father
Bought Her Innocence From Her Father
4.7
When Brian’s obsession with purity spirals out of control, he finds the perfect girlfriend in Natalie—sweet, untouched, and desperate to escape her predatory father. But when her dad tries to sell her to pay off his gambling debts, Brian makes a deal with the devil to claim her innocence for himself. In a world where love, trust, and betrayal are for sale, how far will he go to possess the only thing he believes is pure?
His Mistress Escaped the House of Corpses
His Mistress Escaped the House of Corpses
4.7
Aubrey was lured to a frozen farmhouse by the town’s golden boy, only to be thrown into a nightmare of captivity and horror. Forced to seduce and steal for Derek—the charming monster who kept dozens of bodies beneath his floorboards—Aubrey’s only hope is to claw her way out before she becomes the next corpse. But as she confesses the truth to a rookie cop, her final secret could bring down Maple Heights forever.
Kidnapped by My CEO Ex: Succubus Scandal
Kidnapped by My CEO Ex: Succubus Scandal
4.8
Three years of steamy games and savage Yelp reviews—until my family tries to auction me off to a perfect stranger. Now my possessive CEO ex has gone full dark mode, hunting me down before I can escape. But neither of us knows we’re both hiding demonic secrets, and if he catches me, it won’t just be my heart on the line—it’ll be my soul.
Kidnapped by the Governor’s Son
Kidnapped by the Governor’s Son
5.0
Forced to be her stepsister’s errand girl, an unloved foster daughter stumbles into a deadly game when she kidnaps the Governor’s infamous son. As twisted family loyalty and dangerous secrets close in, she must choose: betray her own heart, or become the villain’s next victim. One wrong move, and everything she’s ever known could burn.
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
4.8
I thought I was gaming my way home—until I realized I’d seduced the wrong man: Chase Milton, the infamous horror boss who hates men like me. Now I’m trapped as his college roommate, desperate to hide my secret and survive a year without losing my head… or my heart. But when the truth comes out, will he destroy me, or is the real danger falling for the monster I unleashed?
Cursed by the Parade Marshal
Cursed by the Parade Marshal
4.9
Caleb, a small-town pastor with a haunted past, is drawn into a desperate family's nightmare after a sacred parade goes wrong. As dark forces threaten to destroy everything Natalie loves, Caleb must face secrets and spirits older than the town itself. Their only hope is faith—and each other—before Maple Heights is swallowed by evil.
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
4.8
For three years, I was forced to slip into the Callahan heir’s bed, a shadow of his fragile wife—my own identity erased in the darkness. When I begged for a place in his world, he offered only cold rejection and cruel truths: I was nothing but a servant, never worthy of love or status. Desperate to save my sister from a worse fate, I offered myself as a widow bride to a dying man—trading one gilded cage for another, as the man I secretly loved watched in stunned silence.