Stolen by My Sister / Chapter 4: Out in the Cold
Stolen by My Sister

Stolen by My Sister

Author: Melissa Mason


Chapter 4: Out in the Cold

The ticking of the heart monitor was especially harsh in the silence. Every second stretched out, punctuated by the beep of my own stubborn heart. The window showed a sliver of gray morning, dew clinging to the glass.

After a moment, my dad nodded. “After signing the agreement, you must keep this matter secret, and go abroad before they get married.”

His voice was cold, but there was relief in it. A deal struck, another problem managed.

“No problem.” I agreed. “You can leave now.”

I turned my face to the wall, pulling the hospital blanket up, closing myself off.

I pulled the blanket over my head and didn’t look at their expressions anymore.

If I never saw their faces again, maybe I could forget how little I mattered to them.

From beginning to end, after they came in, they never once asked me if I was in pain.

They talked about business, reputation, Lily—never me. Not even a simple, ‘Are you okay?’

My eyes were sore. I gripped my hands tightly, my nails nearly digging into my palms.

The pain was sharp, grounding. At least it reminded me I was still alive.

Since it’s like this, then I don’t want them either.

If family could be traded away, then maybe I was better off without one.

In that suffocating space, I forced back my tears.

I wouldn’t give them the satisfaction of seeing me cry. Not now, not ever again.

I heard footsteps approaching.

A different rhythm—slow, heavier. I braced myself for another round.

The next second, the blanket was gently lifted.

A breath of cool air hit my face. I blinked up, startled, caught between fight and flight.

As fresh air rushed in, I was caught off guard and met Evan McAllister’s eyes.

His gaze was tired, the kind you get after pulling an all-nighter in a college library. There were bruised shadows under his eyes, his hair rumpled for once.

He looked exhausted, with dark circles under his eyes—clearly, he’d been watching over Lily Harper all night.

His shirt was wrinkled, tie loosened, a coffee stain near the cuff. He looked less like my fiancé, more like a man carrying a weight he couldn’t put down.

When his gaze landed on the bandage on my forehead, a complicated emotion flashed through his eyes.

I saw a flicker of guilt, pity, something I couldn’t name. For a split second, I wondered if he might actually care.

“Are you hungry?”

His voice was gentle, almost hopeful—like he wanted to fix everything with a bowl of soup.

“I brought the chicken noodle soup you like. Try it.”

I could smell it—the steam rising from the plastic container, the kind of comfort food you bring someone when you’ve run out of words.

I kept my face blank, my voice cold: “Save it for Lily. I’m not hungry.”

I turned away, pulling the blanket tighter. I wouldn’t let him see me hurt.

Evan frowned, not expecting me to be so cold, a bit displeased. “What are you upset about now?”

His patience was running thin. For once, he wasn’t perfect. There was frustration in his tone, his fingers drumming against the tray table.

He reached out to touch my wound. “Still so stubborn, even when you’re hurt. Does it hurt?”

His hand hovered, gentle but hesitant. I flinched away, not wanting his pity.

I turned my head to avoid him.

He sighed, the sound heavy with disappointment. For a moment, I almost gave in—almost let him see how much I was hurting.

“She’s stable now.” His hand froze in mid-air for a moment, then finally dropped to his side, his knuckles turning white.

His words hung in the air, as if that was supposed to make everything better.

“I’m here now…”

He tried to sound reassuring, but it just made me angrier. Here for who? Me, or his conscience?

I cut him off. “Should I be grateful? Thank you, Mr. McAllister, for taking time out of your busy schedule to bring me a bowl of soup?”

I let every syllable drip with sarcasm. If he was here out of obligation, I didn’t want it.

His eyes darkened, his chest heaving with anger.

I saw the struggle in his face—wanting to yell, wanting to understand. But he just clenched his jaw and wiped the soup from his shirt, jaw tight, not meeting my eyes.

“Maya Harper, do you have to talk to me like this?”

His voice shook, but he held it together, barely. He used my full name, the way people do when they’re at the end of their rope.

“Then how should I talk?” I looked up and met his gaze. “Wish you two a happy ending—would that be enough?”

My voice was raw, stripped bare. I wanted him to know just how much it hurt.

“Maya!” Evan was furious, slamming the bowl down on the cabinet with a loud crash.

The sound made me jump, soup sloshing over the side, broth splattering across the faux wood. Even Evan lost his composure sometimes.

We just stared each other down, the air frozen between us.

For a moment, neither of us breathed. We were two statues in a room full of ghosts.

After a long time, he closed his eyes, suppressing his emotions. “I watched the security footage. You kicked her. Maya, come on, go apologize to her, okay?”

He spoke as if reading a script, trying to sound reasonable. It made my blood boil.

I looked at him and suddenly laughed. “Evan McAllister, you might as well just kill me.”

My laughter was bitter, hollow. I meant every word.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
4.7
Everyone adored my perfect sister—except me, who knew the secrets behind her shining trophies and forced smiles. Raised to sacrifice everything for me, Summer’s only moment of freedom ended in blood and blame, and from that day, her happiness vanished for good. Now she swears she’ll ruin my life, but the truth is, I already ruined hers—and no one in our picture-perfect Ohio town has a clue.
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
4.7
I watched helplessly as my little sister was lured into a nightmare by the girl she trusted most, only to be betrayed and trapped in a cruel small-town ritual. When I tried to save her, they killed me—now I’ve woken in the past, desperate to rewrite fate and stop the wedding night horror before it begins. But the whole town is in on the secret, and one wrong move means losing her forever.
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
4.9
Betrayal doesn’t end with death—it starts all over when you’re given a second chance. Mariah Sinclair lost everything: her team, her future, and her place in her own family, all thanks to a single, misunderstood moment and a sister who wore innocence like armor. But when fate rewinds the clock, Mariah returns to the day it all went wrong—with a heart full of vengeance, a locket that holds ancient secrets, and the ruthless will to survive. In a world where every teammate could be a traitor and every kindness is a weapon, how far will she go to reclaim what was stolen? When forgiveness is a luxury and trust is poison, can Mariah outwit the sister who ruined her, or will history repeat itself—bloodier than before?
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
4.8
On the day of my wedding, I let my conniving half-sister take my place at the altar—giving my childhood fiancé exactly what he wanted. But when he realizes the bride in his arms isn’t me, all hell breaks loose, and the secrets that tore us apart threaten to ruin us all. Betrayed by blood and love, I’ll finally choose my own destiny—even if it means shattering the lives of everyone who ever doubted me.
Stolen by My Stepsister
Stolen by My Stepsister
4.9
Rachel Evans thought her life was picture-perfect—until she’s cast as the villain in someone else’s love story. Betrayed by the girl she treated as a sister and haunted by a barrage of meta commentary only she can see, Rachel must fight for her own survival as secrets, revenge, and fate twist everyone’s future. When everything she loves is threatened, will she play the villain or rewrite the ending?
Sold for the Sullivan Heiress
Sold for the Sullivan Heiress
4.8
My little sister died as a decoy so the Sullivans could survive, and my father called it fortune. Now orphaned and branded by betrayal, I’m forced to serve the girl who once humiliated me—my childhood tormentor, now my master. But as secrets, blood money, and forbidden promises bind us, I’ll do whatever it takes to make them all pay for what they stole from me.
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
4.9
Annie Chen never planned on marrying Ethan Carter, Maple Heights’ most coveted bachelor—until a twist of fate and her sister’s wild warning tie their lives together. But with secrets from a past life, a new rival, and a rugged stranger stirring her heart, Annie must choose between repeating old heartbreak or seizing a chance at forbidden happiness. One man wants her, another saves her, and everyone in town is watching.
My Sister Was Swapped for a Southern Heiress
My Sister Was Swapped for a Southern Heiress
4.7
Taylor returns from her secret mystical training to find her beloved sister changed—forgetful, too perfect, and surrounded by secrets in Savannah’s richest family. When Taylor’s powers reveal her brother-in-law has children that shouldn’t exist, and her sister can’t even remember her own past, she realizes someone has stolen her sister’s life and soul. Now, Taylor must unravel a web of Southern magic, family betrayal, and soul-swapping before her sister is lost forever.
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
4.8
On the night of our engagement, my perfect fiancé was found in bed with my younger sister, destroying both our reputations in front of the entire town. He claimed to have taken advantage of her, choosing her honor over the love he promised me—leaving me to face the shame, heartbreak, and whispers alone. But the real truth is darker, and in Savannah, betrayal is a family tradition.
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
4.9
Sometimes, the person you love most comes back as someone else. When my sister wakes up convinced she's a debutante from another century, my family is thrown into chaos—and I'm the only one who sees the truth behind her haunted eyes. As Lila stumbles through smartphones and SAT prep, I teach her about freedom, love, and the world that should have been hers. But when a car crash swaps our souls across time, I wake up in a past where women are prisoners and my real sister is a ghost. To survive, we must outwit cruel fathers, possessive cousins, and the rules of two different worlds—until a desperate ritual offers one last shot at home. What will we lose to return—and what if the girl we saved is the one we can never let go? When fate gives you a second chance, can you rewrite your own story?
I Fought My Sister’s Monster In-Laws
I Fought My Sister’s Monster In-Laws
4.8
When my sister’s desperate call wakes me at 2AM, I race through the night to save her from her predatory father-in-law—only to find her husband and mother-in-law blaming her instead. Betrayed by the family she married into, I become her only shield as the violence escalates and secrets explode. In a house where blood means nothing and cruelty rules, will I destroy them before they destroy us?