Stolen by My Stepsister / Chapter 2: Frozen Out and Dragged Back In
Stolen by My Stepsister

Stolen by My Stepsister

Author: Stephanie Brown


Chapter 2: Frozen Out and Dragged Back In

2

Natalie took Caleb and left in a rideshare.

Before leaving, she gave me a deep look. “Rachel, you’d better not regret this.”

Regret what?

The moment she closed the door, I immediately froze her debit card. My finger hovered over the app for a split second, anger flaring up—after all these years of sharing everything, this is how she repays me? Still, I hesitated, just for a second, wondering if I was being too harsh. But then I remembered the look in her eyes, the feeling of betrayal, and pressed the button. All these years, eating my food, drinking my drinks, wearing my clothes, and now scheming against me.

Someone whose legs I saved by sending him to the hospital in time, and who repaid me by destroying my family.

Truly a perfect match.

I took a shower, then called someone over for a home spa.

The professional massage was so relaxing it made me drowsy, but Natalie kept calling, one after another.

The sound of the rain mixed with her half-collapsed voice:

“Rachel Evans, what did I ever do to you? Why did you freeze my card? I’m at a motel now, but my card won’t go through. Do you know how embarrassing that is?”

“Ugh, I knew it. When you said you treated me like a real sister, it was all fake. You just want to humiliate me with money.”

As she spoke, I could hear the motel TV blaring in the background—some late-night sitcom laugh track echoing over the buzz of a vending machine down the hall. Somewhere nearby, a couple was arguing, voices muffled but sharp. Her voice cracked at the end, static from the motel phone line mixing with her sniffles. I couldn’t be bothered to argue and just hung up.

But a few minutes later, my parents called.

“Rachel.”

Their voices were low, heavy with disappointment. “We thought you two were like sisters. What happened? It’s not right to kick someone out over a fight.”

“We’ve already told Natalie to go back to you. You two get along.”

I sat up in bed, suddenly alert.

I forgot about my parents.

I can see the barrage, but my parents can’t.

To convince them that the girl they’ve doted on for over twenty years would ruin our family, a few words wouldn’t be enough.

[Hmph, the vicious supporting character really thinks that kicking out the main girl means the main girl is helpless.]

[Supporting characters are destined to be manipulated by the leads, ugh, it’s just pitiful for our Natalie, dragging the main guy through the rain all alone, soaked like a drowned rat.]

Half an hour later, Natalie came back in a sorry state, dragging Caleb with her.

The two of them stood at the door, rain and blood staining my hardwood floor red.

Natalie shivered. “Rachel Evans, why are you bullying me like this?”

Her lips were blue, eyes glassy—she looked like something the cat dragged in. I suppressed my sneer and replied indifferently:

“Oh dear, just look at you. I’m not trying to bully you, I’m just afraid your kindness will get you taken advantage of.”

“We’re two weak girls—what if he…”

Natalie didn’t catch my sarcasm. Her expression finally relaxed a bit.

The barrage was fooled too: [That makes sense, not everyone is as kind-hearted as the main girl.]

[After all, she’s a vicious supporting character. See, this time since the main girl didn’t tell her the main guy’s identity, she didn’t insist on sending him to the hospital.]

Natalie glared at me resentfully. “Hurry up and help me carry him upstairs.”

I glanced at Caleb, my temples throbbing.

Natalie is about six inches shorter than Caleb. Dragging him back and forth on the asphalt, she’d made his already bleeding wounds even worse.

“Are you sure you don’t want to send him to the hospital?”

Natalie looked at me. “Don’t worry about it, I’ll take care of him.”

Fine, fine.

I helped her get Caleb up to the second floor.

But I hold grudges, and the barrage said that in the last life he destroyed my whole family.

So while Natalie was catching her breath on the handrail, I suddenly let go.

My grip loosened, and in a slow-motion tumble worthy of an NFL replay, Caleb slid down the steps. The thud echoed off the banister.

“Rachel Evans! What are you doing!”

Watching him roll down the stairs, I covered my face as if frightened.

“Sorry, he was just too heavy.”

Natalie dragged him up again like a dead weight, already exhausted.

[I feel like the supporting character did that on purpose.]

[Not just a feeling—she did. I saw her eyes shift with bad intentions.]

I sneered, clapped my hands, and went back to my bedroom.

They insisted on coming back—how could I not take my revenge? Still, as I closed my door, a flicker of guilt twisted in my chest. Was I really becoming the villain they wanted me to be?

You may also like

My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
Stolen by My Sister
Stolen by My Sister
5.0
Maya Harper was promised to Evan—until her long-lost sister Lily came back and stole everything she loved, including him. Trapped by her parents’ betrayal and Evan’s divided loyalties, Maya must decide if she’ll walk away for good or expose the truth that could destroy them all. Torn between revenge and heartbreak, can she reclaim her life, or will her family’s lies ruin her forever?
Sold to My Stepbrother for Survival
Sold to My Stepbrother for Survival
4.7
My mother betrayed our country and traded my innocence for her own ambition, casting me as a pawn in her ruthless game. Forced into my stepbrother’s bed to escape my predatory stepfather, I became the ghost princess of a house built on blood and lies. Now, guilt and forbidden love threaten to destroy what little I have left—unless I betray him, too.
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
4.7
Everyone adored my perfect sister—except me, who knew the secrets behind her shining trophies and forced smiles. Raised to sacrifice everything for me, Summer’s only moment of freedom ended in blood and blame, and from that day, her happiness vanished for good. Now she swears she’ll ruin my life, but the truth is, I already ruined hers—and no one in our picture-perfect Ohio town has a clue.
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge
4.9
Betrayal doesn’t end with death—it starts all over when you’re given a second chance. Mariah Sinclair lost everything: her team, her future, and her place in her own family, all thanks to a single, misunderstood moment and a sister who wore innocence like armor. But when fate rewinds the clock, Mariah returns to the day it all went wrong—with a heart full of vengeance, a locket that holds ancient secrets, and the ruthless will to survive. In a world where every teammate could be a traitor and every kindness is a weapon, how far will she go to reclaim what was stolen? When forgiveness is a luxury and trust is poison, can Mariah outwit the sister who ruined her, or will history repeat itself—bloodier than before?
Haunted by My Stepsister’s Secret
Haunted by My Stepsister’s Secret
5.0
Trapped in a sweltering Georgia apartment with her cruel stepfamily, Morgan discovers she can see haunting supernatural comments that just might save her life. As midnight approaches and family secrets explode, Morgan must survive a night of ghosts and betrayal—or finally get revenge for her mother’s death.
My Stepmom’s Secret Destroyed Me
My Stepmom’s Secret Destroyed Me
5.0
On her twelfth birthday, Allison’s world is shattered when her father brings home a new wife and step-sister, igniting a battle for love, loyalty, and survival. As family secrets unravel and tragedy strikes, Allison must fight to be seen in a house that wants to erase her. Will she ever reclaim her father’s love, or will betrayal push her out forever?
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
4.8
On the day of my wedding, I let my conniving half-sister take my place at the altar—giving my childhood fiancé exactly what he wanted. But when he realizes the bride in his arms isn’t me, all hell breaks loose, and the secrets that tore us apart threaten to ruin us all. Betrayed by blood and love, I’ll finally choose my own destiny—even if it means shattering the lives of everyone who ever doubted me.
Stolen by My Cousin
Stolen by My Cousin
4.9
Rachel was born into privilege, promised to the boy next door—until her orphaned cousin Danielle arrives and steals everything she loves. Betrayed by her family and fiancé, Rachel must choose between fighting for her place or burning her old life to the ground. When she finally breaks the rules, all of Maple Heights will never forget what she does next.
Forbidden Steps
Forbidden Steps
5.0
Grace returns to her fractured family, only to find her forbidden love for Mason—her stepbrother—still burning beneath the surface. With gold-diggers circling and old wounds reopened, Grace must choose: sabotage her brother’s wedding for a shot at reclaiming her lost happiness, or finally break free from the past. But in this high-stakes game of love and legacy, nothing stays buried forever.
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
Betrayed by My Sister’s Best Friend
4.7
I watched helplessly as my little sister was lured into a nightmare by the girl she trusted most, only to be betrayed and trapped in a cruel small-town ritual. When I tried to save her, they killed me—now I’ve woken in the past, desperate to rewrite fate and stop the wedding night horror before it begins. But the whole town is in on the secret, and one wrong move means losing her forever.
Sold for the Sullivan Heiress
Sold for the Sullivan Heiress
4.8
My little sister died as a decoy so the Sullivans could survive, and my father called it fortune. Now orphaned and branded by betrayal, I’m forced to serve the girl who once humiliated me—my childhood tormentor, now my master. But as secrets, blood money, and forbidden promises bind us, I’ll do whatever it takes to make them all pay for what they stole from me.