Stolen Hearts in Maple Hollow / Chapter 5: Mason’s Gift and Caleb’s Fury
Stolen Hearts in Maple Hollow

Stolen Hearts in Maple Hollow

Author: Randall Conrad


Chapter 5: Mason’s Gift and Caleb’s Fury

← Prev

5

Tears blurred my vision, leaving me feeling empty and aching inside. I didn’t see anyone on the road and ran straight into someone. “Riah? Wh-what’s wrong, why are you crying?” Someone gently wiped the tears from my face. I blinked hard and finally saw it was my childhood friend, Mason Turner, who lives next door. Seeing me staring at him, Mason awkwardly withdrew his hand, shifting from foot to foot, rubbing the back of his neck.

“You okay, Riah?” We grew up together, as close as siblings. Seeing him, all my unspeakable grievances rushed out. I couldn’t speak, but my tears fell like broken beads, nonstop. Mason panicked. He’s clumsy with words and couldn’t comfort me, soon sweating from worry. “Don’t cry, hey, who upset you? Tell me, I’ll stand up for you, okay? Don’t cry...” I shook my head. Mason’s voice dropped. “Was it Caleb, did he bully you? I’ll make sure he pays!”

I was stunned, and Mason clenched his fists, ready to rush out. I quickly grabbed him. “No... don’t do anything...” But Mason’s eyes were red, and if you looked closely, his body was trembling. He looked at me for a long, long time, then suddenly lowered his voice: “I... I saw you go in last night, and I heard... things.”

My breath caught in my throat. Mason’s face was flushed, jaw clenched, and he wouldn’t meet my eyes. The street was quiet, except for the distant hum of a pickup rolling down Main. I remembered how Mason always had my back—whether it was a scraped knee or a broken heart. But this was different, and I felt exposed, like the whole world could see through me.

I was startled, eyes wide, looking at Mason. His eyes were red and his face was dark. “Mr. and Mrs. Ford went to Chicago to see his sister yesterday. Took the old Chevy, I think. I saw you go into Caleb’s house, and I... I heard...” He suddenly hung his head, his ears turning red. When he looked up again, Mason’s eyes were a little wet. “Riah, he’s not worth it. After all that, he still made you cry. And he’s always flirting with that city girl. If he really cared about you, could he do something like this?”

Mason’s words were heavy, and I felt them settle into my bones. He was right, but it didn’t make the ache any easier. I remembered the times we’d sat on his porch swing, talking about dreams and futures, never imagining we’d end up here—me, broken and him, angry on my behalf. I flashed back to the night he helped me fix my bike after I crashed it into the mailbox, how he always protected me even when I didn’t ask.

Mason’s words were like needles, stabbing my heart, but I couldn’t refute him. With a soft sigh, Mason pressed a small box into my hand. “I know it’s not my place, but… I don’t want you to be sad over someone who doesn’t like you. Take care of yourself. I’m leaving.” Mason hurried away, as if someone was chasing him.

I stared at the box, hands trembling. It was wrapped in a crumpled Walgreens bag, Mason’s handwriting scrawled on the side—‘For Riah.’ The gesture was so gentle, so thoughtful, that my chest tightened. I hugged the box to my chest, wiping my eyes, wanting to call after him but my voice wouldn’t come.

I wiped the tears from my lashes and looked at what he’d given me. When I saw what it was, my heart trembled. No wonder I didn’t see Mason in the fields this morning. He’d just come from the town entrance. Could it be Mason went to the drugstore early this morning to buy this for me... An indescribable feeling welled up in my chest, making my nose sting. I subconsciously didn’t dare think about why Mason did this. Clutching the item in my hand, I just wanted to hurry home.

The little box felt heavy in my palm, its meaning clear as day. I could picture Mason standing in line at the pharmacy, hands stuffed in his jacket pockets, trying not to look nervous. The kindness behind it made my heart ache, and I realized, maybe for the first time, how much he cared.

But as I turned the corner at the edge of Maple Hollow, I met a pair of dark eyes. Startled, the little box in my hand fell to the ground with a soft thud. Under the bright sun, the words "birth control pills" were glaringly obvious. I bent down to pick it up, but a large hand was faster than me. Caleb looked coldly at the item in his hand for two seconds, then suddenly sneered, his voice icy.

“You sure know how to play people, Mariah.”

His words echoed down the empty street, sharp as shattered glass. I felt my cheeks burn, the embarrassment and anger mixing until I couldn’t tell which was stronger. The sun was hot on my back, but I shivered, wishing I could disappear. Caleb’s eyes were darker than ever, and for a moment, I wondered if he’d ever really known me at all. I clenched my fists, vowing that next time, I wouldn’t let him hurt me without a fight.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev

You may also like

Betrayed in Maple Hollow
Betrayed in Maple Hollow
4.9
Dr. Parker gave up her prestigious career to help the struggling farmers of Maple Hollow, only to be blindsided by their greed and betrayal. As small-town politics and backroom deals threaten to destroy everything she’s built, Parker must decide if fighting for justice is worth risking her heart—or if it’s time to walk away for good. In a world where loyalty is a bargaining chip, she’ll discover who’s really worth saving.
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
Broken Crowns, Burning Hearts
Broken Crowns, Burning Hearts
4.8
After a public humiliation and the devastating loss of his beloved Lila, Ethan is swept into a maelstrom of betrayal, political intrigue, and shifting allegiances in Silver Hollow. As Caroline rises to power through manipulation and ruthless ambition, Ethan must navigate heartbreak, guilt, and impossible choices, ultimately facing the harrowing price demanded for Lila’s freedom.
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
The Senator’s Son Broke Her Smile
4.8
When a senator’s twisted heir shatters a farm girl’s body and soul, Maple Heights turns a blind eye—except for one cop. Derek Lane is the only man ruthless enough to drag the town’s monsters into the light, even if it means taking on the Seven Stars Society and the Deacon dynasty. But as secrets bleed and power shields the guilty, can Derek bring justice to a girl whose only crime was honesty?
Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts
Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts
4.9
Lillian thought her bond with Harrison Whitmore was unbreakable—until a cunning rival rewrote the rules of their world. Betrayed and erased from her own story, Lillian must fight for the truth and her own future, even as everything she loves slips away. Will she reclaim her place, or discover a new path beyond heartbreak?
Stolen Hearts, Broken Tomorrows
Stolen Hearts, Broken Tomorrows
4.8
Lauren Evans’ world is turned upside down when a college reunion dare forces her to reconnect with her ex, Mason. What starts as a drunken game spirals into a journey of confronting old wounds, facing public drama, and navigating new opportunities. With her heart torn between love and ambition, Lauren must decide what—and who—she’s willing to fight for. In a whirlwind finale, she discovers that true home isn’t a place, but the person who waits for you through every storm.
Stolen by My Cousin
Stolen by My Cousin
4.9
Rachel was born into privilege, promised to the boy next door—until her orphaned cousin Danielle arrives and steals everything she loves. Betrayed by her family and fiancé, Rachel must choose between fighting for her place or burning her old life to the ground. When she finally breaks the rules, all of Maple Heights will never forget what she does next.
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
4.9
Annie Chen never planned on marrying Ethan Carter, Maple Heights’ most coveted bachelor—until a twist of fate and her sister’s wild warning tie their lives together. But with secrets from a past life, a new rival, and a rugged stranger stirring her heart, Annie must choose between repeating old heartbreak or seizing a chance at forbidden happiness. One man wants her, another saves her, and everyone in town is watching.
Broken Promises, Burning Hearts
Broken Promises, Burning Hearts
4.8
After her sudden death, Harper Lane becomes a ghost, watching her boyfriend Mason only realize his true feelings too late. Through flashbacks and haunting present-day moments, Harper unravels the pain of unrequited love, the cost of self-sacrifice, and ultimately, the freedom that comes from letting go of the past.
Stolen Hearts, Hidden Truths
Stolen Hearts, Hidden Truths
4.8
An ordinary girl, Rosie Carter, is thrust into an arranged marriage with the Governor’s son, Harrison Whitmore, amid rumors, jealousy, and social expectations. Believing Harrison loves another, Rosie struggles with insecurity and isolation—until the truth about Harrison’s feelings and their shared past comes to light, leading to a genuine, hard-won love.
Traded for His First Love
Traded for His First Love
4.9
Natalie Carter thought she’d found safety in her marriage to the governor’s son—until his memories and his first love returned to shatter her world. Torn between pride and heartbreak, Natalie must decide if she’ll let Maple Heights define her worth, or if she’ll fight for a love that was never truly hers. In a town where reputations last forever, one wrong move could cost her everything.
Banished by My Hometown
Banished by My Hometown
4.9
Derek poured his fortune into fixing the road for his small town—only to be betrayed and shut out by the very neighbors he helped. Now, as his family faces public humiliation and the threat of exile, Derek must confront the people of Maple Heights and reclaim what he’s owed. Loyalty, pride, and justice are all on the line when the town turns against its greatest benefactor.