The Legend Who Vanished Overnight / Chapter 2: The Secret in the Attic
The Legend Who Vanished Overnight

The Legend Who Vanished Overnight

Author: Melissa Everett


Chapter 2: The Secret in the Attic

You could tell nobody wanted to be the one to cross that line. But the worry was real.

“Just open the door. I’ll take full responsibility.”

The boss was firm.

Big Mike’s place was in an old walk-up—six floors, no elevator. Everyone was out of breath by the time we got up there.

We huffed and puffed our way up, joking half-heartedly about how Mike must have calves of steel. By the fourth floor, even the fitness buffs were wheezing. No shame.

The Christmas wreath on his door read: “Let the spirit soar, next year will be even better!” Clearly written by him, complete with an exclamation point.

There was something almost childlike about the handwriting—big, looping letters, a little off-center. The exclamation point was thick and bold. No one else in the building would’ve written it like that.

The boss leaned in and sniffed at the crack in the door, then turned to me. “Record this.”

I pulled out my phone and aimed it at the group and the door.

My hands were shaking a little, but I tried to keep the camera steady. The boss wanted everything documented—just in case.

The boss patted the door. “Mike, Mike, you in there? We’re worried about you, so we came to check.”

No answer from inside. And really, none of us expected one.

The silence was thick. It felt like the whole building was listening.

“If you don’t open up, we’re coming in.”

Still nothing.

“Then you agree to us coming in.”

We all exchanged nervous glances, half-hoping for a miracle, half-dreading what we might find.

The boss took a crowbar and slowly worked it into the crack.

It was a hexagonal crowbar, about three feet long, with one sharp end and one flat, bent end. Like something out of Half-Life—Gordon Freeman’s specialty.

Someone behind me muttered, “All we need now is a hazard suit.” Even in tense moments, someone always cracks a joke.

An outward-opening door is harder to pry than an inward one.

Big Mike’s door opened outward. The boss worked at it for a while, but he was experienced, and the lock wasn’t strong.

You could hear the metal groan, the wood creak. Each pop made us flinch, but the boss just kept going, jaw set.

As the door finally opened, my hand holding the phone started to shake.

I was terrified that, just like in the movies, a horrible stench would hit us and there’d be a decomposing body in the living room.

Someone behind me whispered, “Please, God, let him just be out of town.”

Luckily, except for the usual sewer smell, there was nothing else.

The relief was almost dizzying. People let out the breath they’d been holding.

But we still couldn’t be sure.

The fear lingered, thick in the air. Nobody wanted to be the first to step over the threshold.

After the door opened, nobody wanted to go in first. After all, the leader should go first.

We all looked at the boss. He squared his shoulders and stepped forward, setting the crowbar aside.

The boss poked his head in, looked around, then stepped inside.

“Mike? Mike?” we called softly.

Our voices echoed off the walls. The place felt emptier than it should.

It was our first time inside Big Mike’s place. Sometimes, when he drank too much, we’d only ever drop him off at the door.

We’d always joked about what kind of place he kept, but none of us had ever seen it. Now, every step felt like trespassing.

His apartment had a six-plus-one layout, with an attic on the seventh floor.

The staircase to the attic was narrow, tucked behind a door off the main hall. The whole place felt bigger than expected.

Inside, it was spotless. The well-maintained hardwood floor gleamed softly.

You could almost see your reflection in the floorboards. It smelled faintly of lemon polish, like he’d cleaned right before leaving.

The furniture was simple—not old, not new.

There was a lived-in feel—nothing fancy, but nothing out of place. A couple of thrift store finds, maybe, mixed with a sturdy couch and a coffee table stacked with National Geographics.

All three bedrooms faced the sun and were connected to the living room, making the space feel big.

The sunlight poured in, warm and golden. It felt welcoming, but eerily quiet.

I held my phone and entered the first room. It was a tiny study.

The air was still, almost reverent. The walls were lined with books, most of them well-thumbed.

Inside was a reddish-brown desk, a wooden bookshelf, and an empty picture frame on the wall.

The frame was hung a little crooked, as if someone had just taken a photo out. The desk was neatly organized, pens lined up in a row.

On the desk was a sheet of glass, yellowed with age.

It looked like it might have covered a favorite photo or a certificate. I could almost see the outline of something that used to be underneath.

On the bookshelf was a battered Webster’s dictionary and a few elementary school textbooks.

The spines were cracked. Pages dog-eared. Some had doodles in the margins—little trains, stick figures. Maybe Mike kept them for nostalgia. Or maybe they belonged to someone else.

The second room was a spare bedroom, with a double bed. It seemed to be Big Mike’s room.

The sheets were crisp, the bed made military-style. There was a baseball cap on the nightstand, and a small alarm clock ticking quietly.

A train ticket on the headboard caught my eye. One of those rare red tickets.

It was pressed flat under a piece of glass, like a keepsake. The color had faded, but you could still make out the route and date.

The writing was faded, as if it had been rubbed over and over.

There were smudges around the edges, like someone had held it often, tracing the words with their thumb.

On the back was a line from a song: “I want to run away with you, to the farthest town.”

The handwriting was loopy, almost hopeful. It looked like a lyric scribbled in a moment of longing.

Run away with who? To which town? As far as I know, Big Mike never married, and I never heard him mention a girlfriend.

It was one more puzzle piece that didn’t fit. We’d always thought of Mike as a lone wolf, but maybe there was more to the story.

“Damn!” someone yelled from the next room.

My heart started pounding, adrenaline surging.

My grip tightened on my phone. I could hear my own pulse in my ears.

I didn’t expect it, but what had to happen, happened.

We all rushed to the master bedroom, but it was empty.

The tension snapped, replaced by confusion. People looked around, unsure what had caused the outburst.

A colleague stood on the stairs to the attic, waving for us to come up, his face looking like he’d seen something unbelievable.

He was pale, eyes wide, mouth working soundlessly. Whatever he’d found, it wasn’t what we expected.

My breathing sped up, my hand with the phone shook uncontrollably.

I could barely keep the camera steady. My palms were slick with sweat.

I remembered reading a book about a hundred ways to die. One chapter was about how to prevent the smell of a decomposing body from leaking out.

It said:

Putting a corpse in a plastic bag doesn’t work, because the gases from a decomposing human are enough to fill a hot air balloon.

The only way is in high temperatures and dry conditions.

Judging by my colleague’s expression—like he’d seen a ghost—I was sure Big Mike had used that method.

My imagination was running wild. Every horror story I’d ever read flashed through my mind.

I hesitated about going up. I was scared I wouldn’t be able to sleep at night, but curiosity pushed me forward.

Every step made my heart pound, and the creaking stairs made me feel like they might collapse any second.

The attic stairs groaned under our weight. Each step felt like it echoed forever.

Slowly, the attic came into view.

What I saw shocked me even more than if I’d found a dead body.

It was like stepping into another world—a secret universe tucked under the eaves.

In the thousand-square-foot attic was a giant model of a town.

It stretched wall to wall, sprawling across tables and platforms. Tiny houses, roads, trees—everything was there, down to the last detail.

Lakes, rivers, little towns, railways—every detail was a faithful replica of a real place.

You could see the shimmer of water, the glint of sunlight on painted windows. It was beautiful, almost heartbreakingly so.

The colleague who’d called us up found the light switch.

With a flick, the whole scene came alive. Streetlights flickered on, little cars glided along winding roads.

The city lights flickered on, the river began to flow, and a train whistled as it weaved through valleys and town.

A tiny locomotive chugged along its track, smoke curling from its stack. The river sparkled as fiber-optic lights mimicked the sun.

Everyone was stunned. We looked down at this miniature country like giants.

Nobody spoke for a long time. We just stood there, marveling at the care, the patience, the sheer devotion it must have taken.

“This must’ve cost five or six grand, right?” someone guessed.

Someone else whistled low. “No way. That’s at least fifty grand, easy.”

“Five or six grand? More like fifty or sixty thousand,” someone else replied.

There was a collective gasp. We all looked at each other, wondering how Mike had pulled this off. Honestly, I had no idea.

You may also like

He Wasn’t My Son—But We Believed
He Wasn’t My Son—But We Believed
4.9
He vanished at thirteen. Three years later, he reappeared—changed, mysterious, and claiming to be the boy who was lost. When ‘Nate’ returns from the dead, the whole world wants answers: Where has he been? Why does he look—and sound—so different? FBI agent Nancy Whitaker is determined to uncover the truth behind his wild tales of abduction and human experiments, even as the boy basks in newfound fame. But behind every headline and tearful reunion, a darker secret waits to be exposed: the returned son is a masterful impostor, and the greatest con of all is just beginning. How far can one stranger go to steal a life—and will anyone see the truth before it’s too late?
The Killer Vanished, But Her Husband Knows
The Killer Vanished, But Her Husband Knows
4.6
Five years after the brutal murder that shattered Maple Heights, the prime suspect vanished without a trace—leaving only a blood-soaked bedroom, a broken family, and a trail of secret money. As the victim’s grieving husband clings to memories and the killer’s mother guards her son’s secret, the truth festers in the shadows. When the past resurfaces, everyone must confront the horrifying question: What if the real monster never left?
Washed Up in the Immortal Army
Washed Up in the Immortal Army
4.8
Ethan Summers clawed his way from a small-town prodigy to Immortal Realm legend—only to become a faceless soldier, just another number in Heaven’s endless wars. Betrayed by fate, forgotten by history, he wanders the cosmic battlefield, haunted by a love he can never claim and a home he can never return to. But when the broken and the damned cross his path, Ethan must decide: will he die a pawn, or finally seize the destiny the gods denied him?
Haunted by the Midnight Maestro
Haunted by the Midnight Maestro
4.6
Derek came to Chicago chasing stardom, but found himself learning forbidden secrets from a phantom voice haunting the theater’s midnight shadows. As his talent grew, so did the chilling suspicion that the price of his gift was more than just sleepless nights—especially when his confession brought the city’s secret ghost-catchers to the stage. Now, with the truth threatening to destroy him, Derek must choose: expose the supernatural bargain or risk becoming the next legend whispered about in the dark.
Forty Seconds, Forever Gone
Forty Seconds, Forever Gone
5.0
Forty seconds. That’s all it takes for a child to vanish—and for a father’s life to implode. Daniel McCarthy thought he had it all: a loving wife, three beautiful kids, and a hard-won career. But when a single moment of distraction on a quiet Midwest morning turns into every parent’s worst nightmare, the world he built comes crashing down. As rumors swirl and the police scramble for answers, Daniel’s guilt and desperation threaten to tear his family apart. With every passing minute, hope fades and secrets surface—was it fate, or something far more sinister, that took Joshua away? When darkness slips into the heart of the American dream, can a family find their missing son, or will they be haunted forever by the forty seconds that changed everything?
Canceled Overnight: America’s Science Idol Betrayed
Canceled Overnight: America’s Science Idol Betrayed
4.8
Alex Carter was America’s science hero—until a single feud shattered his empire. One snarky comment unleashed a war of words, pitting millions of loyal fans against a lone challenger and exposing secrets that would end his career overnight. As rumors of foreign influence and hidden agendas swirl, the nation’s favorite teacher becomes its most shocking outcast.
He Died, Then Came for Her
He Died, Then Came for Her
4.9
Death is supposed to be the end—so why is Aaron Price, missing and presumed dead after a fatal fall in the haunted Black Ridge Mountains, suddenly haunting the people he loved most? Evan, Aaron’s lifelong best friend, is left reeling by the loss—and by Natalie, the woman both men once loved, who claims Aaron has returned, alive and watching from the shadows. When a night meant for comfort turns into a blood-soaked nightmare and Natalie is murdered by a figure wearing Aaron’s face, Evan is thrust into a spiraling mystery: Was Aaron’s death faked, or has something darker come back from the mountains? Each clue drags Evan deeper into a web of obsession, betrayal, and impossible choices—where every answer only leads to more questions. Is Aaron a ghost, a killer, or something neither man nor myth? How far will Evan go to uncover the truth before he becomes the next to vanish?
I Died, But I Stayed for Him
I Died, But I Stayed for Him
5.0
Death didn’t end my story—it set the stakes. I woke as a ghost, memories erased, bound to the man I once loved: Dr. Harrison, the forensic pathologist tasked with unraveling my brutal murder. As he examines my ruined body, I drift helplessly beside him, piecing together the truth of my death—and the life we almost shared. But the clock is ticking: seven days to reclaim my memories or disappear forever. Each revelation brings heartbreak, rage, and the aching hope that love might survive even death. When Harrison is abducted by my killer, I must make an unthinkable sacrifice—trading my own afterlife for a chance to save him. Will justice or love win, or will I vanish before I can say goodbye?
CEO’s Last Betrayal: My Wife Froze My Fortune
CEO’s Last Betrayal: My Wife Froze My Fortune
4.8
Once the king of my company, now I can’t even remember my wife’s face—early-onset Alzheimer’s is stealing everything from me. As my mind unravels, my loyal protégé hides my decline, but my wife—broken by my secrets—strikes back, freezing our fortune in a bitter divorce. With rivals circling and my legacy in flames, I have one final chance to protect my family before I lose myself forever.
Our Last Legend: The Monkey King Rises
Our Last Legend: The Monkey King Rises
4.8
America stands humiliated, one defeat from erasure, mocked by enemies and betrayed by its own. With nothing left but fading hope, I risk everything to summon a forgotten legend—the wild, rebellious Monkey King. As the world laughs and our people despair, a single name reignites our spirit, and the fight for our nation’s soul begins anew.
Stolen Bride, Branded Forever
Stolen Bride, Branded Forever
5.0
On the night before his wedding, Jason and his fiancée Rachel seal their love with matching tattoos—only for her to vanish without a trace the next day. Five years later, haunted by guilt and longing, Jason uncovers a horrifying clue that could finally bring Rachel home. But the deeper he digs, the more he risks losing himself to the secrets that destroyed their future.
I Returned—And Brought Down a President
I Returned—And Brought Down a President
4.9
A president assassinated in daylight. A disgraced general haunted by ghosts and defeat. As the Republic crumbles and enemies circle, a mysterious young man arrives with a letter, a cure, and a map that could change the fate of the nation. Old wounds reopen as loyalty is tested, secrets unravel, and the next generation of leaders steps out of legend—bearing a trophy that could ignite a revolution. Will hope survive in the shadow of betrayal, or is this the Republic’s final storm?