Traded for His First Love / Chapter 2: The Other Woman
Traded for His First Love

Traded for His First Love

Author: Benjamin Turner


Chapter 2: The Other Woman

In that instant, the world seemed to fall silent.

The hum of the engine, the chatter of Main Street, even the far-off bark of a neighbor’s dog—all of it faded away. All I could hear was my own heartbeat, pounding like a drum.

So, it’s come to this after all.

Ever since Marcus regained his memory, I’d been anxious every day, not daring to mention anything about Aubrey Taylor.

I, who had never prayed before, even began kneeling at my bedside every night.

The old quilt beneath my knees, hands clasped so tight my knuckles ached. I’d never been one for church or prayer circles, but desperation has a way of making you believe in things you never did before.

I prayed that after these two years together, Marcus would be moved by me and let go of his obsession with Aubrey.

But in the end, he spoke the words that shattered all my hopes.

“Let her come up and talk.”

“My love.”

I heard my own voice, dry and faint.

“There are people everywhere on the street. If you let her up, what will folks in Maple Heights say about us?”

And how am I, as your wife, supposed to face anyone…

Small towns have long memories, and Main Street gossip travels faster than the wind. I could already hear the whispers—see the looks at the next Sunday potluck.

“Don’t worry.” Marcus patted the back of my hand. “With me here, no one would dare gossip.”

Bitterness welled up in my heart.

He always made it sound so simple, but I knew that folks in Maple Heights judged in whispers and sideways glances that lasted for years.

At that moment, Aubrey had already opened the truck door and slid inside.

Like a lively sparrow, she dove right into Marcus’s arms.

She didn’t even hesitate, just brushed past me like I was a ghost, her perfume sharp and expensive.

“You big dummy, I knew you still had me in your heart!”

“Hmph, you insisted on leaving back then, so why come looking for me now?”

“So you’re blaming me?” Aubrey pouted. “Believe it or not, I’ll leave again!”

“Enough.”

Marcus pinched her nose.

“Last time I chased after you, I ended up wrecked—literally. I’m not looking to repeat that trainwreck.”

“You’re still young, but pity me—this ‘old man’ who’s a few years older than you.”

“Hmph.”

I stared blankly at the two of them, so intimate and carefree. My heart thudded in my chest, hot and embarrassed, like I’d walked in on a private joke I’d never understand.

At some point, my vision blurred…

We’d been married for two years, and Marcus and I had always treated each other with courtesy and distance.

Only now did I realize that someone could act so boldly with him.

So the man who always seemed steady and reserved before me could also be so lively and playful.

My chest tightened, and for the first time I wondered if I’d ever really known Marcus at all.

You may also like

Traded My Wife for My First Love
Traded My Wife for My First Love
4.7
Derek tricks his loyal wife Natalie into a fake divorce—just to bring his high school sweetheart into their home and erase the past. But when Natalie leaves without a fight, her silence exposes Derek’s guilt and Aubrey’s cruel ambition. He thinks he’s finally free, but the cost of betraying the woman who built his life is just beginning—and their daughter may be the one to pay.
Bought His Love, Lost His Heart
Bought His Love, Lost His Heart
4.7
I paid his rent, funded his dreams, and still, Sean gave his heart to someone else. Now, as a new, eager sugar baby tries to buy my affection with charm and ambition, I wonder if I’m just another transaction in this city of deals. When love is bought and loyalty is always for sale, who’s really using who?
Traded for His Freedom, Never His Heart
Traded for His Freedom, Never His Heart
4.7
To save his disgraced family, Caleb Lin marries me—a nobody with nothing but callused hands and a borrowed name. For three years, I played the loyal wife while he pined for his childhood sweetheart, Grace. Now that his father's name is cleared, all that's left is a divorce agreement and a heart that never truly belonged to me.
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
Ruined By My First Love
Ruined By My First Love
5.0
After being betrayed by the girl he once saved, Derek's world spirals into tragedy and poverty. Years later, when fate throws Natalie back into his life, old wounds bleed and new temptations threaten to destroy what little is left of his soul. He must choose between revenge, forgiveness, and a shot at reclaiming his stolen future.
Traded for the Bridesmaid’s Love
Traded for the Bridesmaid’s Love
4.8
Eight years together, and Marcus erases me with a single word—'childhood friend.' At our friend’s wedding, I watch him give my favorite plush and his heart to another, while the crowd cheers for their new romance. Betrayed and humiliated, I open our hotel room door to hear him with her—and realize the man I loved is gone forever.
Traded for Her Savior’s Debt
Traded for Her Savior’s Debt
4.7
Aubrey spent her life loving Derek—the man who raised her like a princess, only to cast her aside for the woman who lost her legs saving him. Betrayed and accused, Aubrey is forced to apologize for a crime she didn’t commit, realizing she’ll never be chosen, only tolerated. With her heart shattered, she walks away from the only home she’s ever known, determined to reclaim her life and leave the pain behind—but Derek’s cold eyes haunt her every step.
Traded After Twelve Children: The Mistress’s Goodbye
Traded After Twelve Children: The Mistress’s Goodbye
4.9
For twelve years, Cassie bore the heir’s children—twelve in all, only two survived—while his heart belonged to another. Now discarded for his first love and forced to give up everything but a box of ashes, Cassie is traded to a stranger like property. As she steps into the scorching Savannah sun, clutching the remains of her lost children, Cassie faces the world alone—determined that this time, no one will decide her fate but herself.
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
4.8
For three years, I was forced to slip into the Callahan heir’s bed, a shadow of his fragile wife—my own identity erased in the darkness. When I begged for a place in his world, he offered only cold rejection and cruel truths: I was nothing but a servant, never worthy of love or status. Desperate to save my sister from a worse fate, I offered myself as a widow bride to a dying man—trading one gilded cage for another, as the man I secretly loved watched in stunned silence.
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
4.7
Natalie gave up everything—even her Olympic dreams—to protect Caleb, only to discover years later that he never loved her, only repaid a debt. Betrayed by the boy she trusted most and humiliated by his cruel friends, she finally reads the journal that shatters her last hope. Now, with his first love back in town, Natalie must choose: cling to the ghost of his gratitude, or walk away and reclaim her pride before she loses herself forever.
My Enemy Stole My First Love
My Enemy Stole My First Love
5.0
Melissa’s only comfort—her empathy doll—goes missing, stolen by her childhood nemesis Derek, reopening old wounds and forbidden desires. As their tangled past resurfaces, Melissa is forced to confront betrayal, family ruin, and a love she’s tried to bury. But when secrets and shame push her to the edge, one violent act will change everything forever.
Left Behind for His First Love
Left Behind for His First Love
4.7
Caleb promised me forever, but when success called, he took our son and his first love—leaving me with nothing but broken vows and a silent house. In my last life, I waited years for a family that never came back; this time, I’ll walk away before they can shut the door on me again. He chose ambition and another woman—now I choose myself, no matter how much it hurts.