I Became the Witch’s Next Body / Chapter 1: Monsters at the Table
I Became the Witch’s Next Body

I Became the Witch’s Next Body

Author: Diana Good


Chapter 1: Monsters at the Table

Next →

I am a monster. Actually, my whole family are monsters. Yeah, that's the real truth—no sense dressing it up.

Sometimes, the truth is just that blunt—a heavy word dropped like a stone in a pond. The sound just keeps rippling out, even when you try to pretend otherwise. In America, we like to think monsters belong in movies or the woods, but sometimes they're right at the table, passing the potatoes. Yeah, monsters. Right at the table.

Ever since I was little, my parents warned me: never reveal our secret—not theirs, not mine. Not ever. By "them," they meant humans, the regular folks outside our door. I remember pausing, thinking, Not theirs, not mine—nobody’s. It was a rule you felt in your bones.

I remember Mom whispering that to me in the back seat of our old Chevy, her voice low and urgent, like we were on the run, and every headlight was hunting us. Secrets were sacred—the unspoken law of our family... And in a small town, secrets are currency—one slip, and you’re bankrupt.

When the sheet covering the cage was yanked away, sunlight stabbed into my eyes. I tilted my head. Stared right at it. Drawn to the light.

The brightness felt like a slap, but I didn't flinch. I’d spent my whole life in shadows—the sun was a dare, and I was ready to take it. For a second, I almost smiled. Maybe that was stupid, but I couldn’t help it.

"Hey, this thing isn't afraid of sunlight."

"Look at those eyes. Don't forget, we're supposed to take 'em out later." A snort followed, derisive and mean.

"Still alive, huh? Can't burn it, can't drown it. Tough little freak."

Their voices had that Southern drawl—half-lazy, half-menacing. The kind you hear in backwoods bars or at the edge of cornfields at dusk. I could smell their sweat, almost taste the tang of cheap beer, and the metallic scent of blood in the air.

Outside the cage, a couple of people stood around. Some held long whips stained with something dark—the kind of dark you don't want to ask about. Others had thick chains, or heavy batons. My skin prickled.

It was the kind of gathering that made you think of those old Southern horror stories, or back-alley dog fights. Their boots scuffed the dusty barn floor. Eyes glittering with the sick thrill of power. My stomach twisted—monsters, every one. I felt their gaze like knives.

They'd found themselves some new entertainment, arguing over which method would be the most fun. I knew that look. I’d seen it before.

One of them, a bald man with a long whip, came over and kicked the cage. "Hey, you little freak, wanna see your parents?"

His boot rang against the metal, making the whole cage rattle. I could smell the leather, hear the glee in his voice. My insides turned cold. Monsters come in all shapes—and sometimes, they’re just men with too much time and too little conscience. I felt my jaw clench.

I stared at him blankly and nodded.

I didn't trust my voice, even if I’d had one. Just nodded, slow and numb. My heart was a trapped animal. Thudding. Wild.

He grinned, mean as hell, and called out to his crew.

His teeth flashed yellow in the sunlight. The others shuffled closer, anticipation thick as static before a summer storm. My pulse raced.

Not long after, someone walked up carrying two bloody things. I stared. It took me a second to realize.

They were two heads.

Freshly severed, blood still bright red, the eyes wide open, staring at me. He tossed the heads just outside the cage, as close as possible. My stomach heaved.

The heads hit the dirt with a sickening thud, rolling until they stared up at me. My parents. Unblinking, faces twisted with shock and pain. Rolling until they stared up at me. My parents. Unblinking, faces twisted with shock and pain. It was the kind of sight you never shake, not even in your nightmares.

I tried to crawl over, but the shackle on my neck was locked tight, leaving me no room to move.

The iron bit into my skin, cold and unforgiving. I stretched until my muscles burned, but the chain held. I could smell the blood, thick and coppery, mixing with the dust. My fingers clawed at the floor. Desperate. Useless.

"Go on, say hi to them."

The bald man kicked my mother's head. Her beautiful dark hair was ruined, tangled and soaked in blood. I remembered brushing it. Once.

He wasn't done. He wrapped his whip around my father's head and flung it into the air.

The head spun, trailing blood in a grotesque arc, before landing with a wet smack. The laughter that followed was sharp and jagged, cutting through the morning like broken glass. It cut through me, too.

The others burst out laughing, wild and cruel.

It was the kind of laughter you hear at a slaughterhouse or a frat party gone wrong—too loud, too gleeful, too human to be anything but monstrous. I wanted to scream.

Blood splattered onto my face, into my eyes. The world turned red.

Like hell.

The blood was hot, stinging. I blinked, but the world stayed crimson, as if someone had painted over everything with rage and grief.

I lowered my hands, which had been trying to break free from the shackle, and numbly watched the scene.

My hands trembled, but I let them drop. The fight leaked out of me. Like air from a punctured tire. I felt small, cold, and empty—like a kid at the bottom of a well, looking up at a sky that would never notice me.

They didn't kill me. The boss's daughter took a liking to me and wanted me as her pet.

I almost laughed. Seriously? Of all things. I’d seen stray dogs treated better than this. But in their eyes, I was just another trophy, a new toy for Daddy's little princess.

I crouched in the cage, listening to them argue.

Their voices blurred together, rising and falling like a chorus of crows. I hugged my knees, trying to make myself smaller. Invisible.

Originally, after they'd had their fill torturing me, they planned to kill me like my parents. But the boss's daughter stopped them.

"The last ones died too fast. I heard this one can't die or age—perfect. Enough for me to play with."

Her voice was sweet as molasses, but there was a razor hidden in every word. She was the kind of girl who’d drown kittens for sport, then cry at her own birthday party. I shivered.

The bald man was her father. He wiped the blood from his hands with a napkin. "Savannah, this little freak saw me kill her parents with her own eyes. Be careful she doesn't hold a grudge."

Savannah Whitaker walked over in red heels, lifting my chin with a wooden stick. The click of her heels echoed like gunshots. The stick was cold, hard under my chin. Her perfume was thick, almost sickening, and her eyes sparkled with curiosity and something much darker.

Her lips, painted bright red, parted. "These eyes are beautiful."

Of all things to say.

The words hung in the air, almost dreamy. She could’ve been talking about a painting or a new dress. Her gaze lingered, hungry and cold.

Right after the praise, in the next second, the sharp end of the stick suddenly stabbed into my eye.

The pain was white-hot, a bolt of lightning straight to my brain. I jerked back, but the cage held me fast. Blood poured down my cheek, warm and sticky. I gasped, vision spinning.

Not satisfied, she gripped the stick tightly and twisted it around inside my eye. Agony. Blinding. My body convulsed.

I screamed, or tried to. Only hoarse, muffled screams could be heard in the courtyard, because before this, they'd already cut out my tongue. Every nerve on fire.

My mouth opened, but no sound came out—just a wet, gurgling noise. My throat ached from the effort, but I kept trying, desperate for someone, anyone, to hear me. Please. Anyone.

Savannah hated the noise and ordered someone to put a dog muzzle on me. She took out a wooden box, grabbed a writhing black centipede, and stuffed it into my blinded eye. I nearly blacked out.

The muzzle was tight, the leather digging into my cheeks. I tasted blood and metal. The creature writhed, its legs scraping against raw flesh. Darkness swam at the edges of my vision.

Later, I learned the boss's daughter was a witch. I was her seventy-eighth experiment. Seventy-eight. That number stuck with me, like a brand. The thought made my skin crawl.

"Eden, does your eye hurt?" She grinned, all teeth and malice. "Bet it does."

Her tone was almost playful, like a kid teasing a bug with a magnifying glass. I could see her reflection in the glass. Smiling. Always smiling.

I shook my head violently, the iron chain on my neck clanking.

The chain rattled, loud in the quiet room. I wanted to scream, to curse her, but all I could do was shake, my whole body shivering with pain and rage.

Ever since she learned I had freakish healing abilities, every few days she would stuff more bugs into me. She said I was a perfect host. Perfect. Yeah, right.

"Scream! Why don't you scream!"

I clenched my teeth and stayed silent.

My jaw ached, but I refused to give her the satisfaction. If you show weakness, they hit you harder. That’s just how it goes around here.

She stood outside the cage, holding a long whip dipped in something dark. Because no one knew where I came from, they were afraid of what I might be, so they used old superstitions to keep evil away:

"I even gave you a nice name—what more do you want!"

The whip lashed my face, splitting a bloody gash from my left eye down to my jaw. I winced. The pain was sharp, white-hot.

I tasted blood, hot and salty. I bit my tongue. I’d learned early that if you act weak, they just hit harder. No point crying over it.

"Miss." The butler's cold voice came from the door.

Savannah paused, as if doused with cold water, her eyes rolling with impatience. She scowled, but didn’t argue.

The butler urged, "Mr. Whitaker is back."

She threw down the whip and strode out. Her heels clicked in rapid staccato, the whip forgotten on the floor. The air seemed to relax when she left, as if the house itself was relieved. I exhaled, shaky.

The butler, standing at the door, just frowned at my miserable state, then walked away, disgusted.

His lips curled in a sneer, eyes cold as ice. Less than dirt. Just another problem. I shrank back, heat rising in my cheeks.

One moment I was curled up in the cage, shivering. Once they left, I blinked my almost-healed eye and let a cold smile creep onto my lips.

The pain faded, replaced by a chill satisfaction. I could almost taste revenge. Just waiting. Just biding my time.

Late at night, everyone was asleep and the whole mansion was silent.

The Whitaker estate sprawled in the dark, a Southern Gothic nightmare. The old house creaked and groaned, the wind rattling the shutters. Even the moon seemed to keep its distance. My skin prickled with anticipation.

But tonight was too quiet, because the butler had ordered everyone to stay in their rooms.

Except for me.

The sound of iron chains dragging echoed through the house. The corridors were dimly lit, casting the shadow of a hunched figure on the wall. My heart beat faster.

The chain was heavy, scraping against the floorboards. My shadow stretched long and thin, twisting with every step. Old wood. Secrets. The air was thick with them.

On the tray, the bowl of blood was perfectly balanced. The dim light made it glisten with an eerie sheen. The smell made my stomach turn.

The blood was warm, thick, and sticky. It sloshed as I walked, the scent cloying. My own heartbeat thundered in my ears. I swallowed hard.

The destination was the room at the far end, called the black room, which gave off a strange, sweet scent. My skin prickled. Something was off.

The black room was forbidden, a place even the bravest servants avoided. The sweet smell was overpowering, like rotting flowers and burnt sugar. I wrinkled my nose, fighting nausea.

Next →

You may also like

Burned Alive for the Old Witch’s Fortune
Burned Alive for the Old Witch’s Fortune
4.8
Offered $150,000 to burn cash for the dead, I thought I’d found the perfect payday—until the ritual began stealing my youth and feeding it to my client, the charming but monstrous Aunt Martha. Every bill I burned aged me years, while she grew young and beautiful before my eyes. Now I’m trapped, ancient and helpless, as she hunts for the last of the money—and my only hope is a childhood lucky charm and one desperate gamble.
The Pastor Claimed My Fox Spirit Body
The Pastor Claimed My Fox Spirit Body
4.8
I broke into Silver Hollow Church for a taste of forbidden magic, but ended up trapped by a venom-crazed pastor who shattered every vow—leaving my fox spirit branded with his holy mark. Now, hunted by his task force and stripped of my most sacred secret, I’m torn between vengeance and the feverish pull of the man who ruined me. If he exposes what happened that night, I’ll lose my power, my freedom, and my heart.
Reborn to Serve My Villain Daughter
Reborn to Serve My Villain Daughter
4.7
I died as a mother, and was reborn as a maid—only to find the cold, feared mistress of the governor’s mansion is my lost daughter from a past life. Everyone whispers that Mrs. Reynolds is a monster who destroys anyone who crosses her, but I refuse to believe the sweet child I once loved could become so cruel. To protect her and uncover the secrets that broke her soul, I’ll risk everything—even if she never knows who I truly am.
Buried in the Wrong Body
Buried in the Wrong Body
4.9
After thirteen years trapped beneath a cursed artifact, a vengeful spirit is resurrected in the body of Natalie—the Montgomery family’s discarded daughter. Betrayed by blood, Natalie returns to claim the life and justice she was denied. Now, with nothing left to lose, she’ll burn every lie to the ground and force the powerful to finally see her worth.
Reborn as the Mean Girl’s Revenge
Reborn as the Mean Girl’s Revenge
4.7
Alex wakes up in the body of Emily Harper—the school’s fallen queen, framed for stealing the championship trophy and dumped by her cheating club president fiancé. With the real Emily’s ghost watching, Alex unleashes a ruthless side the school’s never seen, turning the tables on her enemies and rewriting the rules of high school power. But as secrets unravel and old flames ignite, will revenge be enough to save Emily’s shattered reputation—or will it destroy them both?
Two Incubi, One Bed: My Accidental Harem
Two Incubi, One Bed: My Accidental Harem
4.7
All I wanted was a gentle, obedient incubus to warm my frozen bed—so why did the delivery guy drop off a brooding bad boy too? Now I’m stuck between two dangerously irresistible demons, both claiming me as their own, and the fine print says there’s no way out. When their rivalry turns heated and my heart’s on the line, will I survive being the prize in their forbidden game?
The Ghost Bride’s Revenge: My Mother Sold Us
The Ghost Bride’s Revenge: My Mother Sold Us
4.8
My mother killed my sister for a dowry, injecting her with tainted blood and forcing a wedding to a cursed heir. Now, as my sister’s vengeful spirit rises in her red bridal dress, both the living and the dead want me dead before dawn. Trapped in a house of blood, betrayal, and greed, I must survive the night—or become the next sacrifice to my family’s sins.
I Fought the Demon in Her Womb
I Fought the Demon in Her Womb
4.9
A demon child isn't born—it's made, in blood and grief. Paranormal investigator Savannah Brooks stumbles into Silver Hollow Estates just as a surge of supernatural energy splits the night sky. A frantic tarot reading, a haunted streamer, and a hundred vengeful spirits are only the beginning. When Savannah finds a terrified pregnant woman at the heart of the chaos, she uncovers a horrifying ritual: a demon spirit forced into an unborn child, fueled by tragedy and revenge. But the true evil is closer than anyone suspects—disguised as family, feeding on heartbreak, and manipulating the living and the dead. As betrayal comes to light and desperate choices are made, Savannah must risk everything to break the cycle before another demon is born. Can she outwit the puppetmaster in the shadows—or will her next exorcism be her last?
I Died for Revenge—Now I Rule
I Died for Revenge—Now I Rule
4.9
Death wasn’t the end for Delaney Brooks—it was just the beginning of her revenge. Tormented by queen bee Savannah and betrayed by everyone she trusted, Delaney’s suffering only deepens when a cursed art retreat to Maple Hollow turns deadly. As classmates die one by one in grotesque, supernatural ways, Delaney’s own buried secrets—and her witch’s blood—rise to the surface. Haunted by ghosts, hunted by villagers, and driven by a need for justice, she faces a choice: become the monster they fear, or let her pain consume her forever. But when the final truth is revealed, and the town’s darkest betrayals come to light, will Delaney claim her power—or be doomed to haunt the place that destroyed her? In Maple Hollow, vengeance is never truly dead. Will Delaney break the cycle, or become the legend the town will never forget?
She Stole My Life, One Smile at a Time
She Stole My Life, One Smile at a Time
4.9
She got skinny overnight—then her eyes disappeared. Harper thought college horror stories were just clickbait until her roommate Autumn’s body warped into something monstrous, classmates vanished, and even her own memories unraveled. No one believes her—not after the bloody visions, the missing puppy, or the night she woke up inside someone else’s skin. As Harper’s world is rewritten around her, she discovers Autumn isn’t just haunted—she’s been replaced by a hunger that preys on jealousy and pain. When Harper’s family is stolen, her mind fractured, and justice impossible, she faces an unthinkable choice: fight back against a monster no one else remembers, or lose herself forever. Will Harper survive the darkness—if she can’t even trust her own reality?
Heartless in Heaven, Hunted by the Fox King
Heartless in Heaven, Hunted by the Fox King
4.8
I betrayed the only man I ever loved—a wild fox shapeshifter—just to ascend to the heavens, leaving him broken and swearing off women like me forever. Now, banished back to earth and forced to forge real bonds, he’s back in my bed, determined to shatter my icy resolve and reclaim my heart. But with my old fiancé lurking and celestial rules stacked against us, loving him again could cost me everything—maybe even my soul.
Reborn to Ruin the Golden Girl
Reborn to Ruin the Golden Girl
4.7
Natalie destroyed my life, then watched as the world cheered her on. Now I've woken up in my old body, seconds before her cruel trap—and this time, I'm not here to play victim. The rich and powerful wrote the rules, but I’ll make them bleed for every lie, even if it turns me into the monster they always claimed I was.